• Announcements

    • UnderDawg

      A Few Simple Rules   05/22/2017

      Sailing Anarchy is a very lightly moderated site. This is by design, to afford a more free atmosphere for discussion. There are plenty of sailing forums you can go to where swearing isn't allowed, confrontation is squelched and, and you can have a moderator finger-wag at you for your attitude. SA tries to avoid that and allow for more adult behavior without moderators editing your posts and whacking knuckles with rulers. We don't have a long list of published "thou shalt nots" either, and this is by design. Too many absolute rules paints us into too many corners. So check the Terms of Service - there IS language there about certain types of behavior that is not permitted. We interpret that lightly and permit a lot of latitude, but we DO reserve the right to take action when something is too extreme to tolerate (too racist, graphic, violent, misogynistic, etc.). Yes, that is subjective, but it allows us discretion. Avoiding a laundry list of rules allows for freedom; don't abuse it. However there ARE a few basic rules that will earn you a suspension, and apparently a brief refresher is in order. 1) Allegations of pedophilia - there is no tolerance for this. So if you make allegations, jokes, innuendo or suggestions about child molestation, child pornography, abuse or inappropriate behavior with minors etc. about someone on this board you will get a time out. This is pretty much automatic; this behavior can have real world effect and is not acceptable. Obviously the subject is not banned when discussion of it is apropos, e.g. talking about an item in the news for instance. But allegations or references directed at or about another poster is verboten. 2) Outing people - providing real world identifiable information about users on the forums who prefer to remain anonymous. Yes, some of us post with our real names - not a problem to use them. However many do NOT, and if you find out someone's name keep it to yourself, first or last. This also goes for other identifying information too - employer information etc. You don't need too many pieces of data to figure out who someone really is these days. Depending on severity you might get anything from a scolding to a suspension - so don't do it. I know it can be confusing sometimes for newcomers, as SA has been around almost twenty years and there are some people that throw their real names around and their current Display Name may not match the name they have out in the public. But if in doubt, you don't want to accidentally out some one so use caution, even if it's a personal friend of yours in real life. 3) Posting While Suspended - If you've earned a timeout (these are fairly rare and hard to get), please observe the suspension. If you create a new account (a "Sock Puppet") and return to the forums to post with it before your suspension is up you WILL get more time added to your original suspension and lose your Socks. This behavior may result a permanent ban, since it shows you have zero respect for the few rules we have and the moderating team that is tasked with supporting them. Check the Terms of Service you agreed to; they apply to the individual agreeing, not the account you created, so don't try to Sea Lawyer us if you get caught. Just don't do it. Those are the three that will almost certainly get you into some trouble. IF YOU SEE SOMEONE DO ONE OF THESE THINGS, please do the following: Refrain from quoting the offending text, it makes the thread cleanup a pain in the rear Press the Report button; it is by far the best way to notify Admins as we will get e-mails. Calling out for Admins in the middle of threads, sending us PM's, etc. - there is no guarantee we will get those in a timely fashion. There are multiple Moderators in multiple time zones around the world, and anyone one of us can handle the Report and all of us will be notified about it. But if you PM one Mod directly and he's off line, the problem will get dealt with much more slowly. Other behaviors that you might want to think twice before doing include: Intentionally disrupting threads and discussions repeatedly. Off topic/content free trolling in threads to disrupt dialog Stalking users around the forums with the intent to disrupt content and discussion Repeated posting of overly graphic or scatological porn content. There are plenty web sites for you to get your freak on, don't do it here. And a brief note to Newbies... No, we will not ban people or censor them for dropping F-bombs on you, using foul language, etc. so please don't report it when one of our members gives you a greeting you may find shocking. We do our best not to censor content here and playing swearword police is not in our job descriptions. Sailing Anarchy is more like a bar than a classroom, so handle it like you would meeting someone a little coarse - don't look for the teacher. Thanks.

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

avantgardaclue

A Class cat v Foiling Moth

37 posts in this topic

Clean said on home page...

 

Our first event of 2010 is the A-Cat Invitational down in Islamorada, FL starting Monday. These sleek and ultra-efficient cats are some of the sexiest things out there, and until the Moths really got going, there was no singlehander faster - and that battle is still not decided. The Class is every bit as developmental and tweaky as the higher-profile foilers, and filled with some of the best multihull sailors anywhere as well as plenty of fun young guns that rock it at 20+ knots.

 

Always assumed that the A Class would be faster, now I'm not sure.

 

What do we reckon?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

There is no question that the Moth has a much higher top speed by as much as 25%. It is hard to get an A up above 22kts and the top speed for the Moth is now just over 30kts with a lot of weekend sailors posting speeds of 28+kts.

 

Around a race course that is a different story. Comparing average A Cat sailors to average Moth sailors the A's are faster around the course. Both boats have their conditions where one is totally dominant so it is a difficult question to answer. It is really dependent on the wind speed and you could probably find a wind speed the Moth gets faster as the wind gets higher and the A can achieve very high speeds in less wind.

 

What you need is one of each since they are the two fastest and coolest single handed boats out there.

 

 

Clean said on home page...

 

Our first event of 2010 is the A-Cat Invitational down in Islamorada, FL starting Monday. These sleek and ultra-efficient cats are some of the sexiest things out there, and until the Moths really got going, there was no singlehander faster - and that battle is still not decided. The Class is every bit as developmental and tweaky as the higher-profile foilers, and filled with some of the best multihull sailors anywhere as well as plenty of fun young guns that rock it at 20+ knots.

 

Always assumed that the A Class would be faster, now I'm not sure.

 

What do we reckon?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
What you need is one of each since they are the two fastest and coolest single handed boats out there.

+1000

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Without sailing them directly against each other I've not got much of an idea, but from a quick trawl on the web I've found A classes are generally being sailed off around 690, with the 18 footer on 685 and the Bloody Mary this weekend had the Moth rated faster than the 18...

Some handicap races have been won on lower PY's than 600 by some of the top Mothies over here but at the end of the day handicaps are rarely right and always vary with conditions.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Does it really matter which is quicker? They are both very cool.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Less than 10 knots, A is faster. Flying a hull at 6 knots, on the wire at 7-8 knots. And you point so much higher upwind. And downwind the moth either has to sail high angles to foil, or lowride.

 

Above 15 knots, the moth is quicker. It goes deeper downwind at much greater speed. Not quite the same pointing ability upwind, but a couple of knots quicker.

 

Between 10-15, down to a sailor's ability.

 

Up until recently I had both so my opinions based on my ability.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Less than 10 knots, A is faster. Flying a hull at 6 knots, on the wire at 7-8 knots. And you point so much higher upwind. And downwind the moth either has to sail high angles to foil, or lowride.

 

Above 15 knots, the moth is quicker. It goes deeper downwind at much greater speed. Not quite the same pointing ability upwind, but a couple of knots quicker.

 

Between 10-15, down to a sailor's ability.

 

Up until recently I had both so my opinions based on my ability.

 

punter, stay with it!

what strikes me as to a big diffence is

more about stuff like the moth fits in two travel packs

and the A has to have a trailer...not flight friendly

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Less than 10 knots, A is faster. Flying a hull at 6 knots, on the wire at 7-8 knots. And you point so much higher upwind. And downwind the moth either has to sail high angles to foil, or lowride.

 

Above 15 knots, the moth is quicker. It goes deeper downwind at much greater speed. Not quite the same pointing ability upwind, but a couple of knots quicker.

 

Between 10-15, down to a sailor's ability.

 

Up until recently I had both so my opinions based on my ability.

 

punter, stay with it!

what strikes me as to a big diffence is

more about stuff like the moth fits in two travel packs

and the A has to have a trailer...not flight friendly

 

Wish I could stay with it, and will probably get another A in the future as they are lovely boats to sail. Only reason I sold is that it is getting little use plus little competition locally, plus new models come out regularly which can cause the value to depreciate quicker than the general age of the boat.

 

Plus living in Singapore means going overseas for regattas is bloody expensive as no other As to share costs with. 40ft containers aren't cheap, plus the transport costs to/from docks are certainly exxy. Sending the moth air freight solves a lot of these cost problems, only a single 11ft box is required.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Had a couple of chances to race along side the A cats at Long Beach. If we ( the Moths) are marginally foiling in say less than 12 knots, then the speed and height the A cats up wind wipes us out. Down range the speed differnetial still isnt great so we cant make it back, and the A cats keep building a lead on us.

 

If there's more breeze say 15s and up then we have speed and better height (not as high as an A cat) upwind, plus our down range speed and VMG is really coming on. At this point I would say we are quicker, and our advantage builds as the wind increases!

 

I am sure Craig and the ABYC A cats boys wil have plenty to say about this.....

 

Ideal weights? Dont know about the A cats but if you look at competitive Moth sailors they seem to range from Si Payne at 67kgs, Bora at 80Kgs and Kevin Hall at 100, all placed in top 10 at Worlds

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

75 kg for the A cat is the minimum weight allowed.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

75Kg is the minimum complete boat weight there is no minimum sailor weight. Worlds have been won with sailors ranging from 75kg-90kg.

 

75 kg for the A cat is the minimum weight allowed.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
75Kg is the minimum complete boat weight there is no minimum sailor weight. Worlds have been won with sailors ranging from 75kg-90kg.

 

75 kg for the A cat is the minimum weight allowed.

 

Damn. Forgot about the sailors.

 

Kind of like pianos and pianists, no?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
What you need is one of each since they are the two fastest and coolest single handed boats out there.

+1000

 

At our Frozen Sheets race on Jan 2nd Mike Lennon sailing his moth off 580 beat a very good F18.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Only one way to find out.

 

 

 

 

FIGHT!!!!!!!!!

 

 

 

Or alternatively I'd happily make use of any free A-cats and do some testing. It might take about a year?!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

it would be cool to have a mixed regatta, a-cats and moths on the same line, same course for three days, nine races. ( i have neither, but I'm just saying..)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Biased but in 10 knots I think a moth would take an a cat uphill and crush downhill.

I have lined up a couple of times

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Isn't this thread all a bit Lordesque?

 

Not with Lord Bora posting in it! That is, assuming that an American dude from Detroit can be knighted by the Queen of England... :lol:

 

Seriously, I completely believe that a Moth could be faster than an A-Cat under certain circumstances. I mean, if you've only got foils in the water, your drag is going to be less than any cat. Even if the cat is "doing the wild thing" (sailing on one hull, with the other hull airborne).

 

Still, I would absolutely love to see a regatta where Moths and A-Cats start together on the same race course! And, of course, you'd need top-notch Moth and A-Cat pilots. Otherwise, it's just going to be the better sailors going faster, regardless of boat.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

FYI: A friend who's not registered here sent me the following message:

 

In late 2003 or 2004, Rohan Veal raced against a bunch of excellent A class skippers and beat them in 5 of 6 races around a course. He also beat a fleet of F18's.....

 

Make of it what you will. If true, this validates my theory about the Moth having less drag (when foiling) than an A-Cat (even when doing the wild thing).

 

I'm stuck with Hobie 14s and 16s for the next few years. So I won't be experiencing either an A-Cat or a Moth in the foreseeable future. In the meantime, I will get out on the water as much as possible and live vicariously, as far as modern boats are concerned. :o

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
FYI: A friend who's not registered here sent me the following message:

 

In late 2003 or 2004, Rohan Veal raced against a bunch of excellent A class skippers and beat them in 5 of 6 races around a course. He also beat a fleet of F18's.....

 

Make of it what you will. If true, this validates my theory about the Moth having less drag (when foiling) than an A-Cat (even when doing the wild thing).

 

I'm stuck with Hobie 14s and 16s for the next few years. So I won't be experiencing either an A-Cat or a Moth in the foreseeable future. In the meantime, I will get out on the water as much as possible and live vicariously, as far as modern boats are concerned. :o

 

Let me answer the original question that started this thread: Who the frig cares?

 

This whole thread is based on the premise that one boat type is faster than another. It doesn't matter in the slightest.

 

A-Cat people are looking for an entirely different experience than people foiling Moths. Since real competition is done against similar boats or a handicap, why is the relative speeds of two very different boats a topic worthy of this level of attention?

 

I know the Northern half of us are in deep freeze and the Southern half is out sailing, but can't we find better things to talk about?

 

--

Bill

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Let me answer the original question that started this thread: Who the frig cares?

 

Exactly. Not to burst any bubbles but if you want the fasted thing powered by wind then go wind surfing.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
FYI: A friend who's not registered here sent me the following message:

 

In late 2003 or 2004, Rohan Veal raced against a bunch of excellent A class skippers and beat them in 5 of 6 races around a course. He also beat a fleet of F18's.....

 

Make of it what you will. If true, this validates my theory about the Moth having less drag (when foiling) than an A-Cat (even when doing the wild thing).

 

I'm stuck with Hobie 14s and 16s for the next few years. So I won't be experiencing either an A-Cat or a Moth in the foreseeable future. In the meantime, I will get out on the water as much as possible and live vicariously, as far as modern boats are concerned. :o

 

Let me answer the original question that started this thread: Who the frig cares?

 

This whole thread is based on the premise that one boat type is faster than another. It doesn't matter in the slightest.

 

A-Cat people are looking for an entirely different experience than people foiling Moths. Since real competition is done against similar boats or a handicap, why is the relative speeds of two very different boats a topic worthy of this level of attention?

 

I know the Northern half of us are in deep freeze and the Southern half is out sailing, but can't we find better things to talk about?

 

--

Bill

 

Why do you reply then?

I think it's interesting, especially for isolated fleets that have no clue how quick they're suppose to sail. But infinite could be right, I don't know what dinghy is quicker than a windsurf in anything over 15kts.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Why do you reply then?

I think it's interesting, especially for isolated fleets that have no clue how quick they're suppose to sail. But infinite could be right, I don't know what dinghy is quicker than a windsurf in anything over 15kts.

 

Pourquoi? Parce que la question avait bien beaucoup des responses s'il y a des conditions de la voile, even without considering the skill of the helm. In low winds, the A-Cat should dominate. In marginal conditions, it is anyone's game. In high winds, the Moth should be faster. Basically, across a wide variety of conditions, sea states and steady versus unsteady winds, drawing any conclusions is probably statistically impossible.

 

The question is looking for a straightforward answer, and there isn't one that can be made. Add in helm skill and it becomes even more impossible to make a determination about actual boat potential.

 

--

Bill

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Why do you reply then?

I think it's interesting, especially for isolated fleets that have no clue how quick they're suppose to sail. But infinite could be right, I don't know what dinghy is quicker than a windsurf in anything over 15kts.

 

Pourquoi? Parce que la question avait bien beaucoup des responses s'il y a des conditions de la voile, even without considering the skill of the helm. In low winds, the A-Cat should dominate. In marginal conditions, it is anyone's game. In high winds, the Moth should be faster. Basically, across a wide variety of conditions, sea states and steady versus unsteady winds, drawing any conclusions is probably statistically impossible.

 

The question is looking for a straightforward answer, and there isn't one that can be made. Add in helm skill and it becomes even more impossible to make a determination about actual boat potential.

 

--

Bill

 

Gees, and now you're swearing!

Spring where are you? We're getting crazy down here.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

uhh, price wise a cheap moth cost what $12,000 and an a cat cost how much cheaper?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Let me answer the original question that started this thread: Who the frig cares?

 

This whole thread is based on the premise that one boat type is faster than another. It doesn't matter in the slightest.

 

A-Cat people are looking for an entirely different experience than people foiling Moths. Since real competition is done against similar boats or a handicap, why is the relative speeds of two very different boats a topic worthy of this level of attention?

 

I know the Northern half of us are in deep freeze and the Southern half is out sailing, but can't we find better things to talk about?

 

--

Bill

 

Agree, who cares, it doesn't really matter.

 

BUT, I disagree about the people/experience--hanging around both, there seems a lot in common between the folks who like As and the Mothies. Both groups/boats:

-tend to be techie

-like box rule/formula as opposed to strict OD

-tinkerers

-some of the highest skilled racers in all of sailing

-trickle up innovations

-apparent wind machines

-sailor experiences flight (either hiking while foiling or trapping flying a hull)

-fast fast fast

-light light light

 

[bottom line on speed comparison FWIT: A-cat faster in low wind and easier to sail fast; Moth much faster top end and harder to sail.]

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
FYI: A friend who's not registered here sent me the following message:

 

In late 2003 or 2004, Rohan Veal raced against a bunch of excellent A class skippers and beat them in 5 of 6 races around a course. He also beat a fleet of F18's.....

 

Make of it what you will.

What I make of it is that you friend isn't so much not registered as banned from posting here. It's funny how he manages to get his bullshit posted nevertheless. (Just for the record, after Rohan had posted it on his blog it was found that they were sailing different courses!)

 

Having said that, it was 2006 and Moths are now sigfnificantly faster. Today, I suspect that once up on foils, a Moth will take out both an A class and F18 cat, without too much difficulty.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Biased but in 10 knots I think a moth would take an a cat uphill and crush downhill.

I have lined up a couple of times

 

Well you are Cat 4 :P

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Let me answer the original question that started this thread: Who the frig cares?

 

Exactly. Not to burst any bubbles but if you want the fasted thing powered by wind then go wind surfing.

 

Iceboats?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think the best thing is to have one of each. One skiff, one Moth, one A Cat, one windsurfer, one kiteboard, one cooler full of suds, and one harem to keep you warm when not on the water. :P

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I think the best thing is to have one of each. One skiff, one Moth, one A Cat, one windsurfer, one kiteboard, one cooler full of suds, and one harem to keep you warm when not on the water. :P

AGREED

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I think the best thing is to have one of each. One skiff, one Moth, one A Cat, one windsurfer, one kiteboard, one cooler full of suds, and one harem to keep you warm when not on the water. :P

 

When you put it that way you should just skip the boats and go right for the herem.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
in right conditions (i.e. fast enough to foil) I am fairly certain the moth is faster

Last summer at Datchet UK a pretty good Mothie turned up for the evening race, over about 1 1/2 hours about 5 laps of a trangular course in about 6 - 10 knots of wind. The Moth smoked the cat fleet lapping all but 2 F16's.

 

However its not really a very fair comparison as the F16's are really struggling to fly a hull continuosly in those conditions and triangular courses are our worst sailing course. I also suspect the guy was a bit of an ace against Mid pack sailors as he could fly the Moth virtually the whole way around the course apart from the occassional dip when he tacked. The other interesting thing was the crazy angles he took which almost always meant he was in clean air, the F16 is only as fast as the line of lasers ahead sometimes in short triangles.

 

Never the less I was impressed as the guy was very fast in somewhat marginal conditions, enough to make me think about building one, sadly there just isn't enough about locally to learn from.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Last summer at Datchet UK

 

Never the less I was impressed as the guy was very fast in somewhat marginal conditions, enough to make me think about building one, sadly there just isn't enough about locally to learn from.

 

Like the 10 odd boats over the motorway at Queen Mary? I'm sure they would love to give you a hand getting going...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Last summer at Datchet UK

 

Never the less I was impressed as the guy was very fast in somewhat marginal conditions, enough to make me think about building one, sadly there just isn't enough about locally to learn from.

 

Like the 10 odd boats over the motorway at Queen Mary? I'm sure they would love to give you a hand getting going...

 

Interesting, my understanding they were mainly non foilers and they weren't very active but that was 12 months or so ago.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites