• Announcements

    • Zapata

      Abbreviated rules   07/28/2017

      Underdawg did an excellent job of explaining the rules.  Here's the simplified version: Don't insinuate Pedo.  Warning and or timeout for a first offense.  PermaFlick for any subsequent offenses Don't out members.  See above for penalties.  Caveat:  if you have ever used your own real name or personal information here on the forums since, like, ever - it doesn't count and you are fair game. If you see spam posts, report it to the mods.  We do not hang out in every thread 24/7 If you see any of the above, report it to the mods by hitting the Report button in the offending post.   We do not take action for foul language, off-subject content, or abusive behavior unless it escalates to persistent stalking.  There may be times that we might warn someone or flick someone for something particularly egregious.  There is no standard, we will know it when we see it.  If you continually report things that do not fall into rules #1 or 2 above, you may very well get a timeout yourself for annoying the Mods with repeated whining.  Use your best judgement. Warnings, timeouts, suspensions and flicks are arbitrary and capricious.  Deal with it.  Welcome to anarchy.   If you are a newbie, there are unwritten rules to adhere to.  They will be explained to you soon enough.  

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

bclovisp

Vendee Globe 2012

Recommended Posts

I like JP Dick's position right now and I think Gabart is doing the right thing by going in JP's direction. I don't like Armel's position.

 

take account of the position of the ice door

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Well, overnight JDP has doubled down on the 'stay west looking for the wind' option, and ALC has stuck to the 'go to the mark' option, and FG is right in-between trying to cover both but now looking to work to the west. Overnight the forecast has shifted to strongly favor JPD's option, with a stronger and sustained wind band coming in from the west, and the direct (short) route to the ice gate (sailing well above Gough) has closed for ALC.

 

Current positions, 3 abreast all in the difficult ridge: (red ALC/BP, green FG/Macif, and blue JPD/VBP)

post-8534-0-80432000-1354025655_thumb.jpg

 

Wind comes in from the west, and jpd gets it first on the 28th (you can see why he is fighting so hard to for the west position)

post-8534-0-81546400-1354025657_thumb.jpg

 

All the front three get good wind by the 29th, but there is still better pressure to the west. And there is a good drag race for a while

post-8534-0-32664200-1354025659_thumb.jpg

 

Then things get complex again on 12/1 as the new high pressure starts pushing in

post-8534-0-77367600-1354025660_thumb.jpg

 

and on 12/2 the high is exactly centered over the Gough starboard mark. This high, and the headwinds above it is what closed the door on ALC's northern direct/short route to the ice gate).

post-8534-0-35191500-1354025662_thumb.jpg

 

Right now, VPD gets to Gough first, and ALC & FG are a tie 12 hrs later, so the shift in forecast overnight earned VPD 12 hrs.

 

The big questions are #1 whether the forecast will shift enough for the northern route to reopen for ALC - I doubt it as this high has been persistent in the long range forecast; and #2 whether the high will just cause a general restart near Gough - that's hard to tell right now but it is forecast to be pretty fast moving so may just flog the fleet quickly and move on without affecting the standing.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Estar, very interesting stuff. If I read it correctly you are using Gouph as a mark for the routing exercise, understand. But what if you took it out and re-run the models with the Aiguilles as the only mark. Sure JPD (and FG) will probably run south of Gouph but what does it give for ALC? Is he able to run down the ridge between the two highs?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Sure JPD (and FG) will probably run south of Gouph but what does it give for ALC? Is he able to run down the ridge between the two highs?

 

gough to starboard, somebody said earlier

 

but i agree that's not fully correct to calculate with gough as a mark because it's allowed to pass anywhere north of gough (of course if gough to stb is mandatory)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

JPD and Gabart are going to be GONE when they hit the southerlies turning to westerlies. Gabart actually did a nice job of bailing out and taking his short term losses to JPD. That is a hard thing to do. Routing should be due south right now. Ignore Gough and the Gate. Ignore the results and the distance to the mark. ALC and AT have fallen into the St Helena trap. My guess is that they don't get out of there for a long time! AT should get out now and take his lumps. My educated guess. Fascinating to watch from the couch!!!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

hey AT, don't you want to protest ? It's supposed to be singlehanded isn't it ?

 

 

this guy seems absolutly crazy ! He probably sniffed too much Sikaflex in his sail locker !

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm all for the progress in singlehanded boats, but geez, these guys are clean shaven. Can't we even show that this is a wilderness adventure by coming back with a thick beard full of crumbs.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If the high really stays that far south, maybe ALC can stay North of the whole mess and beat into it at ~28 degrees S, straight for the cape. I don't know if it's ever been done, but this might be the one time it works. Looks like AT may follow him also. Evans, any chance you can run the router on that option? (and thanks for your great posts!)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

guys, I looked at the option to stay north and keep going for the ice gate. I showed a route that did that yesterday. That was clearly what BP was counting on. But the forecast now has shut that door. The ridge persists too long and BP would be going to slow, and then the high pressure sets up right in the way and would stop it dead. He now has to go close to G island.

 

Below is the routing to the ice gate without considering G island. As you can see it goes just south of G island. This is for 12/4 and you can see the high pressure right in the way of the northern route (and that there is more wind toward the S and W)

 

BP's direct/shortest route was always a risk. Its only very rarely been successful in these RTW races. But for a while the picture was so muddled that no-one knew what the correct path was and a reasonable approach was just to bag as much distance to the mark as possible. We all just have to give JPD great credit for seeing the new picture first and committing to it.

 

We are dealing here with the extreme edge (And beyond) of the forecast accuracy window. So the forecast is very likily to change (you can almost count on it). BP can hope that the more direct path reopens. But I doubt it, as the trend has been to a worse ridge and a worse high.

 

post-8534-0-17144900-1354038354_thumb.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If the high extends any further south it will prevent them all from leaving Gough Island to starboard! We will have boats pinching up just to make Gough Island before diving back south, then up again for the ice gate. Rather inelegant, but I suppose better than ice roulette.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Agreed EStar. If BP's decision to stay north works it will be the move of the race, but he put an awful lot on the line in breaking his cover. It's the kind of move that only Nicolas Troussel gets away with. Hopefully some of that rubbed off.

 

Virbac and Macif are in a reliably good possition. They will be the first to enter the South's "don't break the boat" competition. Great race so far. I hate that Riou hit a channel marker in the middle of the ocean though. Ridiculous that such a thing would find him out there.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It seems to me Jean Piere Dick's westward gamble is backfiring. Clearly he doesn't think he can match the other leaders which is a surprise to me. The boats East have made better speed and course to the gate while JPD sails off the race.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

guys, I looked at the option to stay north and keep going for the ice gate. I showed a route that did that yesterday. That was clearly what BP was counting on. But the forecast now has shut that door. The ridge persists too long and BP would be going to slow, and then the high pressure sets up right in the way and would stop it dead. He now has to go close to G island.

 

Below is the routing to the ice gate without considering G island. As you can see it goes just south of G island. This is for 12/4 and you can see the high pressure right in the way of the northern route (and that there is more wind toward the S and W)

 

BP's direct/shortest route was always a risk. Its only very rarely been successful in these RTW races. But for a while the picture was so muddled that no-one knew what the correct path was and a reasonable approach was just to bag as much distance to the mark as possible. We all just have to give JPD great credit for seeing the new picture first and committing to it.

 

We are dealing here with the extreme edge (And beyond) of the forecast accuracy window. So the forecast is very likily to change (you can almost count on it). BP can hope that the more direct path reopens. But I doubt it, as the trend has been to a worse ridge and a worse high.

 

post-8534-0-17144900-1354038354_thumb.jpg

 

Your plotted chart shows it all.The big question is how many hours the more southern boats have at 20+ knots of boat speed before the front finally reaches BP?

 

The ice gate may well be a `starting gate'.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It seems to me Jean Piere Dick's westward gamble is backfiring. Clearly he doesn't think he can match the other leaders which is a surprise to me. The boats East have made better speed and course to the gate while JPD sails off the race.

 

Wait until the front hits and they arc up. Although since they have to turn left and make G Island it may have the effect of them bringing the breeze back to him but not overtaking.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This race is taking a page from the early Whitbreads. A two thousand mile beat to S.A.? The combination of the southern position of the anticyclone, and the northern position of the ice-gate, viola, a split fleet, the leader intent on sailing to windward, against the southeast trades, while second thru 13? have no choice but to take a southern route, and then north, around the ice-gate.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm not surprised by JP Dick's move to try to find stronger winds, he is one of the best heavy wind sailor of the fleet (remember that he is one of the only one able to keep it with the master himself, the professor, the great the only Mich Dej ! during BWR and last Vendee)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

There is some hope for BP yet!

 

A souther ocean low pushes up a crush zone/trough which gets him out of the ridge and into some wind earlier than the prior forecast. Good drag race for all three boats, but with the wind much further forward for BP than the other two.

post-8534-0-89605700-1354056387_thumb.jpg

 

Then the high creates a real challange right over the track - no wind in the center, not much room between the center and the G island starboard mark, and slow head winds above. How to handle it will depend on exactly where the center goes. VBP & M will hope it goes a bit further north and gives a narrow track of wind just north of G island. BP will hope it stays south and blocks off the southern route.

 

post-8534-0-24075000-1354056390_thumb.jpg

 

Right now, with this routing, VBP & M arrive at the ice gate within minutes of each other and BP is 4 hours later. But remember I am using the same polar for all (which is probably a little slower than these boats). SO in reality its a three way tie right now.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This race is taking a page from the early Whitbreads. A two thousand mile beat to S.A.? The combination of the southern position of the anticyclone, and the northern position of the ice-gate, viola, a split fleet, the leader intent on sailing to windward, against the southeast trades, while second thru 13? have no choice but to take a southern route, and then north, around the ice-gate.

 

Gough Island is at 40 deg S and with this low I think it'll be some hard downwind sailing in the next week.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Someone needs to come up with a betting pool on these things. The intrigue is fantastic. I would bet the farm (and the house and the cars and the kids and all of life's great pleasures) on Macif and JPD. BP is toast to the east!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

There is some hope for BP yet!

 

A souther ocean low pushes up a crush zone/trough which gets him out of the ridge and into some wind earlier than the prior forecast. Good drag race for all three boats, but with the wind much further forward for BP than the other two.

post-8534-0-89605700-1354056387_thumb.jpg

 

Then the high creates a real challange right over the track - no wind in the center, not much room between the center and the G island starboard mark, and slow head winds above. How to handle it will depend on exactly where the center goes. VBP & M will hope it goes a bit further north and gives a narrow track of wind just north of G island. BP will hope it stays south and blocks off the southern route.

 

post-8534-0-24075000-1354056390_thumb.jpg

 

Right now, with this routing, VBP & M arrive at the ice gate within minutes of each other and BP is 4 hours later. But remember I am using the same polar for all (which is probably a little slower than these boats). SO in reality its a three way tie right now.

 

Estar, I'm not sure what the timing of your weather charts are. Does that second chart show the high that follows the low they are hunting? Is there a date on that forecast?

 

If it is, I think they'll get to Gough Island before it. ie I caculate on Google Earth that JPD has less than 1100nm to Gough Island and although they're flapping around now there's a good chance they'll speed up and be there by Friday.

 

My money is on Macif 1st to Gough.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Estar, I'm not sure what the timing of your weather charts are. Does that second chart show the high that follows the low they are hunting? Is there a date on that forecast?

 

Sorry, managed to cut the dates off those, but they are in the jpg names - The first is 11/30 and the second is 12/02. So, yes the high follows.

 

If it is, I think they'll get to Gough Island before it. ie I caculate on Google Earth that JPD has less than 1100nm to Gough Island and although they're flapping around now there's a good chance they'll speed up and be there by Friday.

 

My route for JPD has him sailing 1167nm, at an average speed of 9.5kts = 5 days. My polars do seem a bit slow for these boats (which in this situation may mostly benefit BP, if he is much faster in the light stuff than my polar). But remember, the high rotates counterclockwise, so if they get there earlier, they get head winds (S/SE), which will then slow them down. And the center might still roll over them. So, in that routing they do get to the mark first but then essentially stop (under 5kts of boat speed) for 10 hrs.

 

My personal favorate is JPD. I liked him before the race, and so far in the race he was patient until he saw an opportunity (And he was the first to see it) and then he jumped on it and executed. I also think his experience will prove useful in the stronger downwind stuff. But right now I think its a toss up, and mostly depends on weather factors that we cannot accurately predict so far in the future.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This is on ! JP Dick is starting to touch the wind and Armel is dead stuck ! 11knts vs 3.7

Le Cam's position seems very very good too !

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This race is taking a page from the early Whitbreads. A two thousand mile beat to S.A.? The combination of the southern position of the anticyclone, and the northern position of the ice-gate, viola, a split fleet, the leader intent on sailing to windward, against the southeast trades, while second thru 13? have no choice but to take a southern route, and then north, around the ice-gate.

 

Yeah real interesting to see BP trying to cut across the Helena High --- from the last 3 Volvo's at least we have learned that to reach Capetown fastest, you dip as deep South as you dare on the Western side of the Atlantic, and then ride the lows East to basically south of Capetown, and only then come back up (in the last Volvo it wasn't that extreem, I think I recall in the one before some of the boats hit Capetown heading pretty much North). Not sure if all of those had icegates though.

 

Interesting to follow, now let's hope all remainders stay afloat and in competition and we have another brilliant 60 days to go.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Someone needs to come up with a betting pool on these things. The intrigue is fantastic. I would bet the farm (and the house and the cars and the kids and all of life's great pleasures) on Macif and JPD. BP is toast to the east!

 

West is best ,The boats to the west pick it up first and go over the top of the boats to the east. Always go to the breeze and that's what Macif and others have done . Spot on , Game on.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This is on ! JP Dick is starting to touch the wind and Armel is dead stuck ! 11knts vs 3.7

Le Cam's position seems very very good too !

 

... and even more breeze filling in for JPD, Francois G and J le Cam (the old dog).

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

As predicted, significant fleet compression occured last night, with the 2nd pack to the west sailing up the new wind.

 

11/28: We now have a front row of 5 boats basically in line (BP, HB, CP, M, VBP - east to west). Western end well in the breeze while eastern end still sticky. (yellow track = BP, red=CP, purple=VBP)

 

post-8534-0-78181100-1354103733_thumb.jpg

 

11/29: Breeze fills across the whole front line. Strong running for the western end.

post-8534-0-10086600-1354103744_thumb.jpg

 

11/30: The back of the trough comes to the western boats with wind shifting (SW) to the beam, still with good pressure.

post-8534-0-49576600-1354103745_thumb.jpg

 

12/01: High pressure starting to effect and slow western boats, while still some pressure on the eastern end. Western boats lose A LOT of time here.

post-8534-0-99894000-1354103746_thumb.jpg

 

12/02: Western boats escape out below the high, while eastern boat (BP) may or may not have wind (gribs 5-10kts - very unreliable)

post-8534-0-47086700-1354103748_thumb.jpg

 

12/04: All boats below the high in decent breeze.

post-8534-0-98505200-1354103749_thumb.jpg

 

Looking forward its all about how well boats come thru the high pressure system. In this forecast the boats at the eastern end (BP) and at the western end (VBP) come in first and second, with the middle of the line slower. . . . but that will all depend on how the high plays out.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

you really gotta stop doing this dude !

 

 

I don't know how you say "pétole" in english, (when there is no wind at all) so I translated it by "flat wind"

 

Thanks a lot Estar, it's easier to understand with you !

So it's sure that the western boats will be trapped in the light, but we can't no for sure if it's going to be as light for the eastern boat, is that right ?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

So it's sure that the western boats will be trapped in the light, but we can't no for sure if it's going to be as light for the eastern boat, is that right ?

 

 

Everyone now has a definitive strategy and they (the 5 in the front row) are all posible winners. It's left now to who has the boat speed and some luck with the high pressure.

 

If the western boats are really really fast the next couple days, and the tongue of the high does not stick out east so far/so quickly, then they might slip by in front and escape below it. Right now they look like they will get in front of it, but it is then not sure if they will escape below into the favorable winds, before it rolls over them. If they manage that they will crush the course, because it is fast for them from there to the ice gate. Trickypig thinks they will manage the escape, and things have been trending toward that.

 

The question for BP is just how fast is he in 10-12kt winds from all directions. He should definitely manage to get in front of the high and sail a shorter course but he ends up with less favorable wind direction and less average pressure. Normally I would strongly bet against this routing, but the high pressure moving across the course 'may' block the western guys (or at least make them sail extra distance) and make it work.

 

Right now all we can say is it looks like it is going to be a close thing - I have BP getting to the ice gate 03:46 on dec 7th, VBP +4hours at 07:38, and CP +10 hours at 13:40. But any of that could easily change by 12hrs because the grib files are not very accurate when they say 5-10kts. As you saw in the JPD viedo sometimes when they say that its just zero wind, and sometimes its a decent 12kts of breeze.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

PRB has arrived in Salvador da Bahia (as per the AIS track on Marinetraffic) where they will repair before to decide how to get the boat back to France,

They should hang tight in Brazil for a month or so and then join the fleet in the Atlantic when they get around. Training against the best partners and a spectator boat second to none.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

popo, petole, can be; dead calm.

Or if you mean that special area and want to be more nautical, do a search on horse latitude.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Tactics!! Yeah baby. I reckon JPD is actually in the lead. LeCleac'h is too far east and his 100 mile lead relative to Gough Island is probably not enough to get him there first with the forecast he has. JPD is in a MACIF/Le Cam sandwich right now and the wind channel the forecast is predicting will have them sailing a deep direct course to the mark so it should be VMG sailing so the premium is going to be on boat speed and handling for the next couple days. Then it should be a light air reach over to the ice gate i think.

 

Anybody know what the betting houses have for odds on the race?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I was just given a different (much faster) polar for these boats. It would mean that the front runners will all be able to beat the coming high, and the only question is how fast they can get into the breeze now. This faster polar has the western boats advantaged, as they are already in breeze and don't have to go as far south to duck the high. But still all very close +-4hrs to the ice gate. This polar seems faster than I would expect - it might reflect the designers intentions but we will have to see which one more accurately reflects the single handed real world. The boats seems to be more on the routing suggested by the slower polar I was previously using.

 

post-8534-0-53436100-1354120155_thumb.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Tactics!! Yeah baby. I reckon JPD is actually in the lead. LeCleac'h is too far east and his 100 mile lead relative to Gough Island is probably not enough to get him there first with the forecast he has. JPD is in a MACIF/Le Cam sandwich right now and the wind channel the forecast is predicting will have them sailing a deep direct course to the mark so it should be VMG sailing so the premium is going to be on boat speed and handling for the next couple days. Then it should be a light air reach over to the ice gate i think.

 

Anybody know what the betting houses have for odds on the race?

 

+1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I was just given a different (much faster) polar for these boats. It would mean that the front runners will all be able to beat the coming high, and the only question is how fast they can get into the breeze now. This faster polar has the western boats advantaged, as they are already in breeze and don't have to go as far south to duck the high. But still all very close +-4hrs to the ice gate. This polar seems faster than I would expect - it might reflect the designers intentions but we will have to see which one more accurately reflects the single handed real world. The boats seems to be more on the routing suggested by the slower polar I was previously using.

 

post-8534-0-53436100-1354120155_thumb.jpg

 

Estar, they would be quite a unique set of polars for the Open 60s. Do you have them for an actual Open 60?

 

Are the courses plotted on each respective chart a plot of the best course to sail for that particular synopsis with the same starting point?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Estar, they would be quite a unique set of polars for the Open 60s. Do you have them for an actual Open 60?

 

The slower polar I was using was created by some French virtual sailors observing IMOCA60 actual single-handed racing performance. The faster polar comes from one of the current boat's designers, but he 'made it generic' to scrub out proprietary performance information. I personally think the actual performance this race seems somewhere in-between. If I have time, after this leg I will have enough data to adjust the polar to being a pretty good description (and much better than I have right now) of the front runners, but I will still not be able to differentiate between the boats or skippers.

 

My focus is more on understanding and explaining the weather features and their impact on the race, rather than in predicting the race performance of individual boats. I just want to be able to look forward in time at roughly the right place down the course to see what weather is there - so a 'generic' polar is good enough, but it does need to have the boat speeds reasonably accurate relative to the speed of the systems. Right now I think my 'slow polar' may be 20 or 30% slow, and the 'fast' may be correct for peak speeds on short courses with crew but too fast by 30 or 40% for singled handed RTW.

 

Are the courses plotted on each respective chart a plot of the best course to sail for that particular synopsis with the same starting point?

 

If I understand your question, yes (edit: except of course the optimized course for each boat starts at a different starting point)

 

I am using a standard routing program using the standard 'optimized isochrones' method.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

OK, (after some back and forth with one of the designers in my bad french) I have adjusted the new ('fast') polar - it should be close now.

 

For those who want to know - we have a range of wind speeds across the fleet so I have matched the current boats speeds across the fleet with their current wind speeds and made the polar fit that as accurately as possible without changing the shape of the curves. That makes for 80% of my 'fast' designer's polar. The new average speeds along these routes are BP: 14.6kts, CP:15.8kts, and VBP:17.9kts.

 

At that speed the boats will be clearly in front of the high pressure, and it's basically going to be a drag race all the way from now to the ice gate.

 

Of the three I am tracking that still favors the two ends of the line: putting VBP into the ice gate first, BP in second (+8hrs) and CP third (+10 hrs).

 

However, while this routing says BP should be going quite southerly to get to the stronger winds asap - BP is currently steering a more easterly course (he's doing 150 and the routing says 165 degrees). So, his polar/routing must say that he is still better going further east even if it is in lighter wind. So BP may still have another card to play.

 

12/02 picture where you can see them well in front of the high.

post-8534-0-30381200-1354134497_thumb.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Estar, really great to do the homework on the polars, and to refine the routing. Really you are doing for the Vendee more or less what Stan Honey and his well paid team did for course racing. Thanks for all the hard work.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

a few questions for you Estar.

-What is your routing software ? Is there only one ? If not, do they have the same ?

-Does the routing software takes acount of the waves ?

-Can you set a percentage of speed ? for exemple if the skipper is too tired to go full on, or if the boat is crippled, like you don't have your gennaker anymore, can you set your polars to be without it ?

-When running a course, can you have "and if" set, like for Armel, for exemple, if he sets a "and if I can't achieve the theoretical speed, what happends to my routing in 1 day, 2 days, ...

-Last but not least, can you/do you wan tot/are you allowed to tell us who you are working for ?

 

thanks !

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 



first one from De Broc, If I understood well, he was having trouble with communication before.

 



quite sure that wasn't salad that he plowed !

 



I bet he is the only one still having bread on board ! If that doesn't make him a hippy !


 



sad

 



haaaaa sailing video !

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My guess... looks like the low is slipping south and the west group won't be getting their 30 knot+ winds, 15-25 knots maybe. If the weak front passes over them before friday they'll have a better angle into the island though.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

a few questions for you Estar.

-What is your routing software ? Is there only one ? If not, do they have the same ?

 

There are two main commercial packages: Expedition and Adrena. Maxsea used to be a player but has not kept up. There are couple good but less featured free programs, like QtVlm

 

-Does the routing software takes acount of the waves ?

 

They can, but I am not. One thing to be careful of is that because the weather data is not so accurate, it does not make so much sense to use a lot of time super fine tuning the other stuff (for weather routing, it does make sense to have really accurate polars for other purposes) because it will just get lost in the weather chaos.

 

-Can you set a percentage of speed ? for exemple if the skipper is too tired to go full on, or if the boat is crippled, like you don't have your gennaker anymore, can you set your polars to be without it ?

 

Yes, thats all easy in all the packages.

 

-When running a course, can you have "and if" set, like for Armel, for exemple, if he sets a "and if I can't achieve the theoretical speed, what happends to my routing in 1 day, 2 days, ...

 

Some things like that are available in the two pro packages, but a lot of scenario analysis you still have to do manually. I would guess that tools for scenario analysis will become a more developed feature in future releases.

 

-Last but not least, can you/do you wan tot/are you allowed to tell us who you are working for ?

 

Just a fan at the moment, doing this for fun and education. But in the past I have been 'owners rep' on a couple builds and rebuilds and know some of the French and Italian players as a result.

 

thanks !

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My guess... looks like the low is slipping south and the west group won't be getting their 30 knot+ winds, 15-25 knots maybe. If the weak front passes over them before friday they'll have a better angle into the island though.

 

Agreed

 

For the latest gfs gribs (note: I presume the racers are getting meto france gribs rather than gfs) and a bit old positions now . . .

 

for JPD from now all the way to the ice gate: (I would think just about exactly how he would like it . . . we can see how it changes)

10 -15kts= 2%

15-20kts=28%

20-25kts=49%

+25kts = 21%

 

For BP:

10-15kts: 29%

15-20kts:38%

20-25kts:37%

+25kts: 3%

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Expedition routing is very close to that of virtual wind posted above by Estar.

 

it does seem to have the boats I routed staying ahead of the front.

 

I used the polars from here:

 

http://daysailer.wor...60-2/#more-2390

 

Yes your routing and polars are the best bet; but I like the idea that with just over 600 miles to go to Gough Island and the front looming, there is only computer modelling and no weather stations to place it on the chart mid ocean, so maybe there's a chance it'll come sooner and everyone gets a crack at the lead.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

There is no actual requirement to go anywhere near Gouph Island is there - it just has to be to stbd?

 

True. In the virtual Vendée Globe there's a whole pack of players sailing closely by the African coast. And as you have to be north of the first gate at least for a bit that in itself makes for no additional problem.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Expedition routing is very close to that of virtual wind posted above by Estar.

 

it does seem to have the boats I routed staying ahead of the front.

 

I used the polars from here:

 

http://daysailer.wor...60-2/#more-2390

 

Great work everyone, thanks.

 

Re: the Bluewater polars. I assume from Estar's comments that these are potential rather than likely when shorthanded (especially for long durations). With the performance drop off occurring at about 30kts for anything forward of 150deg I have two questions for you shorthanded and designer guys out there.

 

Does the realistic performance drop off occur earlier because you are reducing sail plan earlier or is it more because you don't have enough hands to constantly steer, trim, peel, reef, eat, sleep, etc.?

 

What are these guys actually looking for? Max wind compared to the others or nice, steady 20-25kts? Or, do they get to the point where (subject to extremes) wind angle is more important than strength?

 

Thanks.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

For those interested AT live link up answering questions posted to his FB page..... @ 1230GMT (Nov 29th) on .http://www.alexthomsonracing.com/

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Estar, thanks for your excellent posts. At first sight.. what do you think about the followers, is it possible Bubi's pack can pass before the high closes the gate?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites



is this hair even real ?It has to be a wig !



seems like a PR requested video, but with Le Roi Jean, it turns funny !



Put this fucking mic next to your fucking mouth ! Subtitling is already hard enough, If I can't hear, it just turns impossible !
Bertrand seems quite stressed and disapointed, surely due to his dalayed start



Estar, thanks for your excellent posts. At first sight.. what do you think about the followers, is it possible Bubi's pack can pass before the high closes the gate?


At today's vacation, Bertrand DeBroc said that he thinks Bubi can make it, but not him

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Estar, thanks for your excellent posts. At first sight.. what do you think about the followers, is it possible Bubi's pack can pass before the high closes the gate?

 

I second the thanks to Estar - makes following the race so much more interesting. I'd also like to know what the outlook is for Bubi and the 'chasing pack'. They've been quietly making up lots of miles in the last few days but will they be able to bank them?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

We still have a front row of five boats, but as expected the middle of the line has sagged back a little and the back markers to the west have closed.

 

The finish order at the icegate right now (based on position only, remember I am using the same polar for all) is:

 

#1 VBP

#2 M +4hrs

#3 BP +7hrs (much slower average speed, but less distance sailed)

#4 SC +8hrs (The king hunts down the brits!!!!, highest average speed)

#5 CP +10hrs

#6 HB +13hrs

#7 G +15hrs

 

11/29: BP still in lightish winds, everyone else in decent breeeze

post-8534-0-77697000-1354194729_thumb.jpg

 

11/29 midnight: BP finally gets the breeze and accelerates. You can also see (as Trickypig suggested) that the fleet misses the highest +30kt winds (yellow area).

post-8534-0-27178300-1354194731_thumb.jpg

 

11/30pm: Wind shift to SW on back of the trough just starting to hit western end of fleet

post-8534-0-35728600-1354194734_thumb.jpg

 

12/01: all boats in the SW wind

post-8534-0-91443100-1354194735_thumb.jpg

 

Average speed along these routes:

VBP: 18.1kts (distance sailed 1577nm)

M: 17.4kts

BP: 15.1kts (distance sailed 1428nm)

SC 18.6kts

 

VBP's wind distribution along his route:

10-15kts: 8%

15-20kts:30%

20-25kts:32%

25-30kts:30%

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

the chasing pack is doing quite well. It'll be interesting to see whether Bubi can make a move. He should catch up a bit as he's bringing the wind with him and he seems to have the boat at full chat. Arnaud is making a move as well but he might be a bit too far west to avoid the softer winds after the shift. BdB and TdL are more likely a bit too far behind.

 

One thing i don't understand about the course shown on the VG tracker is the orthodromic route they show implies that Gough Island is to be left to port rather than starboard. It's a bit of a pain for looking at the tracker... What's the rule about the gates? Do they just have to touch the gate line or cross is from a specific direction or what?

 

Looking forward the top 8 should all be in the south in the same system as MG said which will require them to push in the Indian Ocean (fun for us but not for them <_< ) but the Kerguelen ice gate (I think) screws things up a bit as it may very make it necessary to go between the Kerguelens and Heard Island which isn't necessarily what you'd prefer as the shallow water there can make for bad seas. Also having two gates (Aigulles and Kerguelen) so close together restricts the course a bit much IMHO.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

you really gotta stop doing this dude !

 

 

I don't know how you say "pétole" in english, (when there is no wind at all) so I translated it by "flat wind"

 

Thanks a lot Estar, it's easier to understand with you !

So it's sure that the western boats will be trapped in the light, but we can't no for sure if it's going to be as light for the eastern boat, is that right ?

 

I would say..."fart wind" nope?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

thanks again to popo and estar,

If only the sailors would start filming themselves doing a tack/gybe or a sail change I understand it might be too long for the lower budget campaign but for the leaders it should be affordable and it would make great viewing, and shouldn't entail much more that a well placed gopro or whatever they're using. anyone else agree?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

arguments against that:

(1) seems like some of them are using handhelds.

(2) tacks and gybes contain confidential or proprietary steps that the teams don't want to reveal

(3) Would you want someone filming you at work?

(4) a lot of the interesting stuff is invisible (ballast tanks, canting keel) or un-interesting to most non-sailors (stacking)

 

I think there are some vids out there of this done during training that you can find

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Some of them are probably filming those maneuvers but:

-it makes a long clip, that need some editing/cutting

-they are too busy or haven't got enough skills for that

-it would be very very expensive and power consuming to send the whole file

-most probably will be edited after the race , or sometime later in the race if they have a break (difficult but not imposible)

 

For example Bubi sent this one yesterday after climbing the mast 10 days ago , but he didnt have the time to edit it before..

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

One thing i don't understand about the course shown on the VG tracker is the orthodromic route they show implies that Gough Island is to be left to port rather than starboard. It's a bit of a pain for looking at the tracker... What's the rule about the gates? Do they just have to touch the gate line or cross is from a specific direction or what?

From the VG website -

 

An Ice Gate is a segment on a given latitude, defined between two longitudes. The space between the longitudes is around 400 miles, the equivalent of one and a half day of sailing. There are four to six, or sometimes seven gates along the route and they are spaced out between 800 and 2,000 miles. In order to validate their crossing, skippers only need to sail through the gate from north to south, from south to north, or just keeping sailing north.

 

More.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

We still have a front row of five boats, but as expected the middle of the line has sagged back a little and the back markers to the west have closed.

 

The finish order at the icegate right now (based on position only, remember I am using the same polar for all) is:

 

#1 VBP

#2 M +4hrs

#3 BP +7hrs (much slower average speed, but less distance sailed)

#4 SC +8hrs (The king hunts down the brits!!!!, highest average speed)

#5 CP +10hrs

#6 HB +13hrs

#7 G +15hrs.

 

Funny you should mention the polars.. As much as I would like to see le Cam/SC beat Stamm/CP to the ice gate, it looks as though Stamm/CP will be in good breeze shortly and his amazing boat speed should prevail. I think le Cleac/BP is going to struggle as he has to sail deeper angles to meet the pressure.

 

The Vendee tracker shows the front arriving in the next 24 hours but Passageweather.com shows it arriving later.

 

I found a website for a South African research station there and saw their weather observation page but unfortunately the last observations were in 2010. http://www.sanap.ac....ugh_weather.php

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Dick is on fire ! More than 20 knots !

With the flat water he should have, this must be awesome and "easy" !

 

You're welcome all for your thanks, you'll have to wait a little bit for today's videos, I've been trapped by a bottle tonight !

 

Le Cleac'h was speaking this morning about the differences there is between UE and US gribs files.

Did you tried both Estar ?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Expedition routing is very close to that of virtual wind posted above by Estar.

 

it does seem to have the boats I routed staying ahead of the front.

 

I used the polars from here:

 

http://daysailer.wor...60-2/#more-2390

 

Yes your routing and polars are the best bet; but I like the idea that with just over 600 miles to go to Gough Island and the front looming, there is only computer modelling and no weather stations to place it on the chart mid ocean, so maybe there's a chance it'll come sooner and everyone gets a crack at the lead.

 

Indeed, weather models lack surface data / weather balloon sounding data over the big oceans. However, don't forget that a massive amount of satellite observations are included (surface winds, vertical humidity profiles and a lot more) which allows to localise fronts. So, models are less accurate than on the NH, but definitely do better than providing `model weather'. That ended for the southern oceans around 1979.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

One thing i don't understand about the course shown on the VG tracker is the orthodromic route they show implies that Gough Island is to be left to port rather than starboard. It's a bit of a pain for looking at the tracker... What's the rule about the gates? Do they just have to touch the gate line or cross is from a specific direction or what?

From the VG website -

 

An Ice Gate is a segment on a given latitude, defined between two longitudes. The space between the longitudes is around 400 miles, the equivalent of one and a half day of sailing. There are four to six, or sometimes seven gates along the route and they are spaced out between 800 and 2,000 miles. In order to validate their crossing, skippers only need to sail through the gate from north to south, from south to north, or just keeping sailing north.

 

More.

 

Must be something lost in translation; I understand "sail through the gate from north to south, from south to north" but not sure what "or just keeping sailing north" means. Does it mean keep completely north of the gate?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites