Jump to content


alone


  • Please log in to reply
18 replies to this topic

#1 Editor

Editor

    Anarchist

  • Moderators
  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 5,673 posts

Posted 20 August 2012 - 05:57 AM

how it went down

alone

There has been a fair bit of discussion about the sinking of the Sonoma 30 Cowabunga off Hawaii, and below is the story from Mike Hanson who was one of the crew during this harrowing incident. There are many lessons to be learned here...

It was a half hour past midnight when we noticed the boat was filling up. We had heard water sloshing around in the cabin, and when we shined our flashlights below, it was already about eighteen inches deep. We fumbled for a few minutes trying to manually remove the water with the hand-operated bilge pump, but we soon realized this was no ordinary leak. It was blowing 18 knots with five foot seas in the middle of the Kauai channel, and our ship was sinking.
Kenith Scott was on the helm at the time, and he immediately told everyone to unclip from the safety harnesses that attached us to the boat. Zach Denzer, who’s dad Mark owned the boat, dashed below to get life jackets and the radio. He got on channel 16 to notify the Coast Guard that we were taking on water, and also activated our Emergency Position Indicating Radio Beacon (EPIRB) while the rest of the crew dawned life jackets. Zach then grabbed a bucket and began bailing the water out of the cabin. I took the helm from Kenith, who joined Zach below. They bailed for several minutes, but the water was coming in faster than they could empty it. I shined my flashlight into the pitch black cabin to aid their efforts. Random pieces of gear were floating in the water, which was now up to their knees. Abandoning the thought of isolating the source of the leak, our situation had become frantic. We called in the May Day.

Jamile Qureshi, a merchant marine who we brought aboard as our navigator, handled the radio communication with the Coast Guard. He had the littlest sailing experience of the entire crew, as this was his first major racing venture. Despite his lack of actual sailing experience, he demonstrated his maritime ability as he deftly handled the radio communication with the Coast Guard, staying in constant contact, using the hand held GPS to update them with our exact coordinates every ten minutes or so. There was also a second, personal EPIRB, which we activated and wrapped around the wrist of Bree Nidds, one of the two female members of our crew.

Tate Wester began shooting off flares, which sparked upon ignition, but failed to light up the night sky. There was a forty-footer about ten miles ahead of us, and if we were able to signal them, maybe they could assist us. Yet the sky remained dark as our flares failed, and we knew our sole hope was a Coast Guard rescue.

Despite the intensity of the situation—the swell beating at the side of the boat, the failing flares, the water rising in the bottom of the cockpit, the steady communication with the Coast Guard kept us fairly collected. There was some initial panic when we realized we were sinking in the middle of the channel, but we clung to each radio transmission, a sure sign that we were going to be alright.

In the meantime, I trimmed the mainsail to keep us into the wind. The boat was filling up fast now and the last thing we wanted was a capsize. We all agreed that if we ended up having to ditch the boat, it would be pivotal to stay together. We readied lines to tie to each other, and gathered the most important gear. We had two EPIRBS, a hand-held VHF radio, a hand-held GPS, a strobe-light, a bag of life jackets to hold on to, and a large water cooler with several waters and Gatorades. It didn’t even cross our minds to salvage cell phones or wallets—mere trifles in such a circumstance.

By now the crew members had taken shifts down below bailing out water, and eventually getting sea-sick. I tried to steady the boat, but as we sank lower and lower, the steering became more unstable. Water began to flood over the transom and into the cabin.
Quite honestly, I was in a daze most of the time, as I had already thrown up from sea sickness before the boat even began to sink. But there was a moment when I looked away from the crew, over my shoulder at the black ocean and the waves lapping and asked myself if this would be the way it all would end. I kept this to myself, and was brought back to the crew by the voice of Kenith, who assured us to all stay calm, as the Coast Guard had just deployed a rescue helicopter from Barber’s Point on Oahu.

By now waves were crashing directly into the cabin, and we knew the boat was going down fast. When the side stays were underwater, we all dipped off the transom, kicking ourselves as far away from the boat as possible.

We watched it drift away from us. It sank straight down, never leaning to one side or the other. The water was over the entire cabin top, and eventually the spreaders, until all that was left was the mast-head-light glistening against the black night sky. It dipped down below the surface, and we were left in complete darkness, huddled together in the middle of the ocean, thirty miles away from land.

From here, minutes went by like hours. Jamile notified the Coast Guard that the ship had sank, and that we were now adrift at sea. He was still able to relay our coordinates, holding the VHF and GPS above the water. They told us it would be about a half hour before they would reach us. All we could do was wait.

Every little light in the sky seemed like rescue. We saw planes, shooting stars, distant lights from shore, all of which raised our hopes to the highest exaltation, only to let us plummet down as the helicopter failed to materialize.

At this point, Kenith, a veteran of the Iraq War, said something I will never forget. “Man, I fought a war, and this is about the hairiest situation I have ever been in.” We all said a little prayer to ourselves, trying to fight off the thought of sharks, or whether or not the helicopter would find us, and just clung to each other, waiting.

About twenty minutes later we saw a headlight on the horizon. It was coming towards us. We heard the thunder from the helicopter blades low over the water. A Coast Guard chopper flew directly overhead, shining their search light down on us, and eventually even passing us. There was a little panic as we thought they had missed us. Jamile even radioed in to tell them, but the Coast Guard station assured us that we had been spotted, and the helicopter was just making an approach on our position.

Minutes later the chopper approached from leeward, deploying a rescue swimmer. I wanted to watch every move they made, but the water from the blades shot up from the waves like needles. The diver swam up to us, asking if anyone was injured, assessing the state of each member of the crew. At this point I became sick again, though the fact that we were being rescued should have revitalized me, I was dry-heaving when the diver swam up to us.

He told us that four of us were to be airlifted out on the helicopter, while three would have to stay back in a life raft. First to be airlifted was Lani Johnson, the other female member of our crew, then myself, as I was in probably the roughest shape of anyone, then Bree, and then Tate.
The rescue swimmer brought me over to the dangling rescue cage, placed me in, and told me to sit on my hands to keep them from banging against the helicopter. I was winched up to safety, swaying back and froth in the wind as the cage rose higher. One of the crew members brought me into the cabin where Lani awaited. We immediately hugged and watched the cage go back down for Bree, and then again for Tate. They deployed a life raft for the three other members of our crew and the rescue swimmer. From the helicopter, I could see the strobe light bouncing around in the waves below.

With the life-raft deployed we turned around and headed for Lihue. I sat by the window and looked up at the stars over the ocean. I looked at the faces of the members of our crew, all of us in shock. And as much as I wanted to tell them how much I cared for them and how glad I was to be alive, the motor from the helicopter drowned out any form of verbal communication. That was the loneliest part of the night for me, being so close to my friends, but unable to tell them how happy I was that we made it through.

Eventually we landed back on Kauai, where we were escorted to the fire station, and eventually to the Coast Guard station where we met up with the other three members of our crew. After some logistical issues of not being able to buy flights or board the planes without identification or proper foot wear, we made it back to Oahu on an afternoon flight. We were met with T.V. cameras and reporters at the airport. We smiled for the cameras and took our interviews, watching every day people walk by on the way to their flights, some staring at us awkwardly, others oblivious.

Days earlier, our crew was briefed by Zach’s dad on all of the safety equipment on the boat. He showed us how to operate the two EPIRBS, the VHF, the GPS, the life jackets and safety harnesses. All of the batteries were replaced in our equipment, new rigging was put on the boat, all the screws were tightened and every piece of gear accounted for. We were as prepared as we could have been for what we went through, and though it never crossed our minds that we might have to abandon ship, I am proud of every member of the crew for how they handled the situation. Bree Nidds is 20 years old. I am 21. Tate Wester is 22. Lani Johnson and Zach Denzer are 23. Kenith Scott is 26, and Jamile Qureshi is 35. We were by far the youngest crew sailing back that night, but no one freaked out, everyone stuck together, and we made it through the night.

I have learned many things from racing sailboats. I have learned how to make decisions, prioritize my actions, adapt to shifts both on the water and in my life. I have learned that sometimes you’re up and other times you’re down, and it is always crucial to focus on the task at hand. I have never in my experience, however, thought that sailing would teach me to cope with the threat of death. There is nothing that can prepare you for that. And had our EPIRB’s failed, or had our VHF batteries been dead, it could have been a very different story.

The steps you take to prepare yourself for a sailing venture, however threatening or non threatening you think it may be, could very well save your life when a situation becomes dire. As long as you don’t let that situation get away from you, and remain confident in the steps you have taken to prepare, nothing should stop you from casting off and sailing into that horizon.

#2 hobot

hobot

    Anarchist

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 10,327 posts
  • Location:Riggers Hollow Archipelago, Wa. USA

Posted 20 August 2012 - 08:30 AM

Thank you very much for posting your story.

#3 tomtom

tomtom

    Anarchist

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 210 posts

Posted 20 August 2012 - 09:08 AM



Days earlier, our crew was briefed by Zach's dad on all of the safety equipment on the boat. He showed us how to operate the two EPIRBS, the VHF, the GPS, the life jackets and safety harnesses. All of the batteries were replaced in our equipment, new rigging was put on the boat, all the screws were tightened and every piece of gear accounted for. We were as prepared as we could have been for what we went through, and though it never crossed our minds that we might have to abandon ship, I am proud of every member of the crew for how they handled the situation. Bree Nidds is 20 years old. I am 21. Tate Wester is 22. Lani Johnson and Zach Denzer are 23. Kenith Scott is 26, and Jamile Qureshi is 35. We were by far the youngest crew sailing back that night, but no one freaked out, everyone stuck together, and we made it through the night.



Good story, but it does raise one question to me: why wasn't there a life raft on board? They are not that big and expensive anymore, and any situation that could require an EPIRB, could also require a life raft?

#4 opa1

opa1

    Anarchist

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 595 posts
  • Location:Palm Beach Gardens, Florida
  • Interests:Golf, Sailing

Posted 20 August 2012 - 11:51 AM

I agree on the life raft. I am surprised that this was not required gear for a race of this nature. This story now reminds me to check all our life saving gear, to include flairs, for an upcoming ocean race. Out-Of-Sight, Out-Of-Mind doesn't make it for life saving gear. Seems like all aboard handled this desperate situation in a calm and orderly fashion. Kudos to them, and glad they survived, in tact. Too bad they lost the boat. The Sonoma 30 is a great boat. Did they ever figure out what caused the leaking?

#5 killapenguin

killapenguin

    Member

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 72 posts
  • Location:Honolulu, HI

Posted 20 August 2012 - 01:26 PM

I don't believe that a life raft should be required for this type of race. Although the conditions can be rough, the race occurs in a channel between two islands, with rescue available within a couple of hours at most (assuming that the boat carries an EPIRB, VHF, etc.). The water is ~75-77 F, so hypothermia should not be an issue in that period of time. (http://www.seagrant....ies/hypothermia)

Looking at some other well-known west coast races, the distance for the Kauai Channel Race is about twice that of the fully crewed Farallones race (for which no life raft is required from what I can tell), and about 1/2 that of the Newport to Ensenada Race (for which a life raft is required).

It should also be noted that the sinking occurred after the race during the delivery back to Oahu, so even if a life raft were required for the race, it's possible that it wouldn't still be on the boat (although it probably would be).

I'd be interested to hear others' opinions about what type of conditions would merit the organizing authority to require a life raft.

#6 Tucky

Tucky

    Anarchist

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 2,691 posts
  • Location:Maine

Posted 20 August 2012 - 02:40 PM

I don't believe that a life raft should be required for this type of race. Although the conditions can be rough, the race occurs in a channel between two islands, with rescue available within a couple of hours at most (assuming that the boat carries an EPIRB, VHF, etc.). The water is ~75-77 F, so hypothermia should not be an issue in that period of time. (http://www.seagrant....ies/hypothermia)

Looking at some other well-known west coast races, the distance for the Kauai Channel Race is about twice that of the fully crewed Farallones race (for which no life raft is required from what I can tell), and about 1/2 that of the Newport to Ensenada Race (for which a life raft is required).

It should also be noted that the sinking occurred after the race during the delivery back to Oahu, so even if a life raft were required for the race, it's possible that it wouldn't still be on the boat (although it probably would be).

I'd be interested to hear others' opinions about what type of conditions would merit the organizing authority to require a life raft.



Independent of a requirement to carry a liferaft, this story is a reminder of the need to consider carrying a liferaft on a boat that can sink.



#7 fstued

fstued

    Newbie

  • Members
  • Pip
  • 13 posts
  • Location:San Diego
  • Interests:sailing racing a bit as long as I am having fun

Posted 20 August 2012 - 03:31 PM

for yrs I carried an uninflated inflatable to pass the safety requirements for ocean races It was a joke had it been needed it would have take 1/2 hr to inflate. Pretty stupid on my part lucky we never needed it. I got a newer boat and spent the $1200+ for a real life raft. and hopefully I'll never need it and it will never be inflated But I am sure glad I have it. It stores easier than the phony one is lighter has very easy access and I feel a whole lot safe thee stories reinforce my decision to buy a real life raft.
Fstued

#8 cap10ed

cap10ed

    Anarchist

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 688 posts
  • Location:next door
  • Interests:delete account

Posted 20 August 2012 - 03:34 PM

Great story. Any thought as to what caused such a massive amount of water to flood the vessel?.

The steps you take to prepare yourself for a sailing venture, however threatening or non threatening you think it may be, could very well save your life when a situation becomes dire. As long as you don't let that situation get away from you, and remain confident in the steps you have taken to prepare, nothing should stop you from casting off and sailing into that horizon.





#9 jkdubs808

jkdubs808

    Anarchist

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 2,761 posts
  • Location:Sebastian, FL
  • Interests:Sportboats and offshore supply vessels......and bow girls.

Posted 20 August 2012 - 03:46 PM

I know the owner, and know the boat well having grown up in Hawaii. The owner still doesn't know what could have caused it, but when he asked what I thought my only suggestion was possible delaming issues near the keel. Thats the only way I can think of that water could keep coming in at that high of a rate. This Sonoma 30 had a stern hung rudder, so the water didn't come in from the rudder post. The mast didn't punch through the bottom of the hull when it dropped off a wave........no inboard engine either. The only possible explanation I can think of is delamination somewhere near the bottom of the boat where water could continuously come in. Mark (the owner) keeps his boat in VERY good shape....so I was very surprised to hear about her sinking.


As for the life raft issue, on the distance races between the islands it has never been mandatory to carry a liferaft. There is no real overnight races, and the CG is well informed of when these races are happening. This sinking happened on the delivery back to Oahu from Kauai after the Kauai Channel Race. Not disagreeing the issue, just stating the facts of Hawaii racing.

#10 Ryley

Ryley

    Anarchist

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 3,050 posts
  • Location:Boston, MA
  • Interests:Sailing, Photography, Sailing, Mountain Biking.. did I mention sailing?

Posted 20 August 2012 - 05:10 PM

I know the owner, and know the boat well having grown up in Hawaii. The owner still doesn't know what could have caused it, but when he asked what I thought my only suggestion was possible delaming issues near the keel. Thats the only way I can think of that water could keep coming in at that high of a rate. This Sonoma 30 had a stern hung rudder, so the water didn't come in from the rudder post. The mast didn't punch through the bottom of the hull when it dropped off a wave........no inboard engine either. The only possible explanation I can think of is delamination somewhere near the bottom of the boat where water could continuously come in. Mark (the owner) keeps his boat in VERY good shape....so I was very surprised to hear about her sinking.


As for the life raft issue, on the distance races between the islands it has never been mandatory to carry a liferaft. There is no real overnight races, and the CG is well informed of when these races are happening. This sinking happened on the delivery back to Oahu from Kauai after the Kauai Channel Race. Not disagreeing the issue, just stating the facts of Hawaii racing.


Could it have been the knotmeter or depth sounder? that'd be a big enough hole to cause some serious flooding, more as the boat got lower in the water...

#11 One eye Jack

One eye Jack

    Anarchist

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 1,186 posts
  • Location:Reno,Nv. San Francisco Bay , Santa Cruz,Ca. Tahoe,Nv
  • Interests:Sailing. I shot a man in Reno.. Just to watch him die..

Posted 20 August 2012 - 08:36 PM

When is an old boat to old? It is getting to be where the age of the boat isn't even considered, look at Green Buffalo a Cal 40, or all of the pre 90s ULDBs . Then you see things like that maxi hat started to fall apart after only a couple of years. But no body really ever talks about the keel bolts, except maybe Rambler and Charlie. But if you think about it those keel bolts are in some kind of corrosive (salt water) possible electrolysis, stretching from being the only thing that holds the keel onto the boat .they normally are stainless, but stainless does corrode over time.Or get fatigue.like others said ,it might have been delamination, but maybe one of the keel bolts fanally said screw it I've had it and cracked or broke. Even with drop keels you can get corrosion with any part in the water. That boating. You can either drop the keel, check the bolts, rebed and reattach the keel, or you might be able to have the whole keel bolt are Xrayed by structural steel inspectors. Then if any cracking or stress it should show up. We will never know what happened to this boat. The water is just to deep or costly to find out. This is just a thought.

#12 rule69

rule69

    Anarchist

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 1,726 posts

Posted 21 August 2012 - 04:51 AM

Could it have been the knotmeter or depth sounder? that'd be a big enough hole to cause some serious flooding, more as the boat got lower in the water...


I gather (2nd hand) that the only thru-hull of any kind was the knot meter. Delam seems more likely to me but...?

#13 rgscpat

rgscpat

    Anarchist

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 708 posts
  • Location:New Mexico/southwest USA
  • Interests:sailing, racing, race management, Desert Sea / southwest USA sailing, future of sailing, travel, photography, hiking

Posted 21 August 2012 - 09:24 AM

As far as I know, a grand or two doesn't get much of a life raft these days, just those so-called survival platforms, single-tube small capacity coastal rafts, etc., with laughably minimal survival gear on board. While items like EPIRBs have gotten cheap, I haven't seen decent cheap life rafts.

#14 jkdubs808

jkdubs808

    Anarchist

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 2,761 posts
  • Location:Sebastian, FL
  • Interests:Sportboats and offshore supply vessels......and bow girls.

Posted 21 August 2012 - 09:55 AM


I know the owner, and know the boat well having grown up in Hawaii. The owner still doesn't know what could have caused it, but when he asked what I thought my only suggestion was possible delaming issues near the keel. Thats the only way I can think of that water could keep coming in at that high of a rate. This Sonoma 30 had a stern hung rudder, so the water didn't come in from the rudder post. The mast didn't punch through the bottom of the hull when it dropped off a wave........no inboard engine either. The only possible explanation I can think of is delamination somewhere near the bottom of the boat where water could continuously come in. Mark (the owner) keeps his boat in VERY good shape....so I was very surprised to hear about her sinking.


As for the life raft issue, on the distance races between the islands it has never been mandatory to carry a liferaft. There is no real overnight races, and the CG is well informed of when these races are happening. This sinking happened on the delivery back to Oahu from Kauai after the Kauai Channel Race. Not disagreeing the issue, just stating the facts of Hawaii racing.


Could it have been the knotmeter or depth sounder? that'd be a big enough hole to cause some serious flooding, more as the boat got lower in the water...


rule69 is right, the only through hull was the knot meter. Could it have been that? Absolutely. Whos knows, and one eyed jack is right, there is no recovering the boat in that channel.......not with the massive currents at the various depths and the 800-1000 foot depths either. We can speculate all we want, never know the answer unfortunately.

I 100% agree with the post about the keel bolts. Been on boats where we lost a rig, punched a whole in the hull, broke a rudder, busted the boom, man overboard.......but I have never been on a boat that lost the keel. That one worries me the most.

#15 fastyacht

fastyacht

    Anarchist

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 3,283 posts

Posted 29 August 2012 - 01:53 AM

When is an old boat to old? It is getting to be where the age of the boat isn't even considered, look at Green Buffalo a Cal 40, or all of the pre 90s ULDBs . Then you see things like that maxi hat started to fall apart after only a couple of years. But no body really ever talks about the keel bolts, except maybe Rambler and Charlie. But if you think about it those keel bolts are in some kind of corrosive (salt water) possible electrolysis, stretching from being the only thing that holds the keel onto the boat .they normally are stainless, but stainless does corrode over time.Or get fatigue.like others said ,it might have been delamination, but maybe one of the keel bolts finally said screw it I've had it and cracked or broke. Even with drop keels you can get corrosion with any part in the water. That boating. You can either drop the keel, check the bolts, rebed and reattach the keel, or you might be able to have the whole keel bolt are Xrayed by structural steel inspectors. Then if any cracking or stress it should show up. We will never know what happened to this boat. The water is just to deep or costly to find out. This is just a thought.


I talk about keels rather frequently. There are many other stories of either lost live (Coyote, and the Wiley boat that went over in SF Bay some years back with the loss of a J24 champion) or near misses (Drum, Dolphin & Youth, Melges 30). And All those canting keels that fall off in the southern ocean. Autissier lost one, didn't she?

You probably never heard of Dolphin & Youth. She was a Whitbread 60 designed by Humphries and skippered by an unrelated Humphries. In the Southern Ocean west of Chile, they found some of the bolts were failing. They got on the satphone to the design office and figured out what to do. The story was related to me by one of her crew--because after the Transatlantic Race in '93, I talked to him while he was filling and fairing the cracks in the putty around the keel joint. I said to him at the time something to the effect that "if it is flexing enough to do that, I'd worry about the structural integrity.

Frankly, I think one of the weakest areas in yacht design is the engineering of keel attachment. Look through the records and you will be shocked how often this happens, over and over again, nobody learning from other previous mistakes.

#16 fastyacht

fastyacht

    Anarchist

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 3,283 posts

Posted 29 August 2012 - 02:05 AM

At the Workboat show in Providence some years back, a Lobsterman turned inventor had a display of an inflatable "life preserver" for boats. It was quite clever. Went around the gunwale. Of course if I remember correctly, he had learned the hard way.

Some years earlier I was working on a self-rescue aid and doing a patent search. I found all sorts of ideas, some whacky some not. As I perused the patents, one jumped out at me, because I saw a classic Eastern lobsterboat hull in the sketch. I had to call the guy. Sure enough, it was a lobsterman Down East (a different one from the story above). He had lost his boat once, and had this idea of how to find the darned thing so he could go get it!

#17 Great Red Shark

Great Red Shark

    Anarchist

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 5,666 posts
  • Location:Honolulu

Posted 29 August 2012 - 02:08 AM

I talk about keels rather frequently. ... and the Wiley boat that went over in SF Bay some years back with the loss of a J24 champion


Could you be talking about the death of Larry Klein ? He was a J/24 champ, But that wasn't a Wylie, nor did they lose the keel. The boat was a modified Hobie33 with racks and it was the racks that failed and put the crew in the water. Facts matter.

#18 fastyacht

fastyacht

    Anarchist

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 3,283 posts

Posted 29 August 2012 - 07:48 AM


I talk about keels rather frequently. ... and the Wiley boat that went over in SF Bay some years back with the loss of a J24 champion


Could you be talking about the death of Larry Klein ? He was a J/24 champ, But that wasn't a Wylie, nor did they lose the keel. The boat was a modified Hobie33 with racks and it was the racks that failed and put the crew in the water. Facts matter.


Thank you for the correction. My memory was faulty.

http://articles.lati...1_larry-klein/3

#19 Crazyi

Crazyi

    Newbie

  • Members
  • Pip
  • 1 posts

Posted 30 August 2012 - 04:35 AM

Tater et al

This is the one experience no sailor wants to talk about...... Good on you all for calm heads and prep. I cannot wait to welcome you home to Orcas where your training started! Let us know when you are in port,dinner is on us,

Lots to talk about lets meet, glad you all beat the sharks!

Doc




0 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users