Cruzan Single Barrel for sipping.
Black Strap on the rocks ain't too shabby either. Trick is finding the St. Croix distilled and bottled version.
No kidding. I live here and we have not seen Single Barrel in the stores for some time. Checked Cost-U-More, Plaza Extra, Pueblo, K-Mart, various petrol stations and have not seen the Single Barrel for a while. I think it must all be going up to Babylon.
Try adding a dash of Angostura Bitters to the Black Strap on the rocks, quite good. I also order my Crucian version of a Dark and Stormy at the yacht club, Black Strap and Ginger Beer. Not sure what it means that the bartender remembered me after more than a month.
For regular sipping, the 2 year old in the 1.75 litre for 12.29 (recently went up, fuckers). I remember when Woolworth's was going out of business we could get the 750mL for 1.99.
Sadly they no longer make the Rum Cream, which was great in that Sunday morning coffee.
Belize has some interesting rums. I still have a bottle from the early 1990's (empty) of "Belize Extra Strong Rum" which had a simple label with a sailing ship on it. No indication of the proof or anything. Good stuff but be careful.
My wife brought back a bottle of El Dorado 12 year old rum from Guyana, very, very good sipping rum.