another evergreen containership runs aground, this time in Chesapeake bay near Baltimore

Crash

Super Anarchist
5,369
1,225
SoCal
The investigation also found that the pilot only used one piece of equipment — his Portable Pilot Unit — to navigate the vessel and did not use any of the ships charts or equipment or navigational buoys that marked the channel’s southern turn. The report said that if the pilot had used “all available means to determine the ship’s location, the grounding likely would not have occurred.”

Thanks for posting this and the results came out before the NTSB would've put them up. Not at all surprised by the findings regarding the pilot being totally inattentive.

Everybody in this area is aware of the numerous buoys leading into the turn and counting down the numbers, the straight line of buoys going off to the right from the turn in front of you are super conspicuous, and the shoreline features are both identifiable and fairly close. For anybody who has been near the Craigshill turn even just few times, missing it is inconceivable.

Us locals know to stay the heck out of the way when the big ships come through there because they do it faster than our little boats can top out in speed, and they take a lot of space doing so. Put a sailboat even near the channel markers of the turn and the ships lay on the horn.

In aviation, we have what's called the 10,000 foot rule for landing, aka "silent cockpit." It used to be that all the way to the ground airline pilots would joke, talk about union stuff, home life, plans, the hot stewardess in back, etc. The NTSB found poor cockpit management in a number of accidents and recommended the FAA pass the rule. Since then once below 10,000 feet, commercial pilots are not allowed to discuss anything other than the landing approach. Cockpit voice recorders are occasionally pulled for audits (FAA required flight operations quality assurance program, or FOQA) and being heard violating the rule can result in a written reprimand.

There are Coast Guard rules about critical phases of operation, but they are paper tigers since there's no follow up similar to FOQA.

(fwiw - My avatar is from being a retired NTSB aviation accident investigator and the name of my boat is Airworthy.)
While I agree and concur with the principle you are talking about, typically with airliners "run aground" hundreds of people die...When a containership runs aground, typically there are no fatalities. This is not meant, in anyway, to excuse the exceedingly poor seamanship the pilot exhibited, and he should loose he license and qualification to pilot...at least for some period of time.
 

Foreverslow

Super Anarchist
While I agree and concur with the principle you are talking about, typically with airliners "run aground" hundreds of people die...When a containership runs aground, typically there are no fatalities. This is not meant, in anyway, to excuse the exceedingly poor seamanship the pilot exhibited, and he should loose he license and qualification to pilot...at least for some period of time.
No break given. We all know the saying "You had just ONE job to do.."

And there are instances of loss of life due to pilot fuckups. Skyway bridge disaster in Tampa killed 35.

The one good aspect is the US gov was quick and open on this.
Remember Egyptian officials holding Ever Grand responsible when everything points to their pilot screwing up while shaking down the boat for smokes.
Where is that report? It happened a year earlier and nothing but crickets.
Difference between a 1st and 3rd world country
 

Talchotali

Capt. Marvel's Wise Friend
844
528
Vancouverium BC
Consent decree:


Also, a new phone policy for pilots:


$676K fine for Evergreen:

 

nolatom

Super Anarchist
3,777
786
New Orleans

An outfit calling itself “Marine Insight” doesn’t know the difference between a ship Captain, and the compulsory local Pilot?

The pilot let his cellphone completely distract him from a necessary course change. He’s the one being canned.
 

garland823

New member
37
28
An outfit calling itself “Marine Insight” doesn’t know the difference between a ship Captain, and the compulsory local Pilot?

The pilot let his cellphone completely distract him from a necessary course change. He’s the one being canned.
Pretty rich for the state to mandate the ship take on a pilot from the state's pilot association, and then demand $676k from the ship's owner when the state's pilot runs the ship aground.
 

kent_island_sailor

Super Anarchist
28,556
6,307
Kent Island!
Pretty rich for the state to mandate the ship take on a pilot from the state's pilot association, and then demand $676k from the ship's owner when the state's pilot runs the ship aground.
I hadn't thought of that.
1. Require the hiring of pilots.
2. Supply stupid pilots.
3. Fine ships for running aground due to step 2.
4. Profit! :D :D
 

Tacoma Mud Flats

Have star, will steer by

Mitigation plan for Ever Forward grounding​



Said report:


"...The M/V Ever Forward grounded in legal charted oyster bar NOB 4-2. Whether mitigation occurs for this intrusion is to be determined by the various agencies involved..."​
"...The U.S. Coast Guard issued its report on the grounding citing the lack of attention by the ship’s pilot who they reported was using a cellphone and texting when the ship missed a critical turn on its route in the Chesapeake Bay. They also called for better training by Evergreen and other shipping companies of their bridge crews citing that the team on the bridge was aware that the ship missed the turn but did not directly alert the pilot..."

"...citing that the team on the bridge was aware that the ship missed the turn but did not directly alert the pilot..." -- For that finding, likely Evergreen's insurance company copped a deal and $677K was an acceptable payout.
 

huey 2

Super Anarchist
4,115
2,222
syd
1675170811134.png
 
Top