in the air

Editor

Administrator
Staff member
6,704
1,137
carlsbad
what-is-it-5-27.jpg


Okay yes, it is a bulb keel. Is there anything more?

 

Starboard!!

Member
328
105
The elusive shoal draft bulb keel option?

Judging by the size of it, did they substitute playdough for the lead?

 
Last edited by a moderator:

ryley

Super Anarchist
5,571
704
Boston, MA
why don't they just go back to IOR and fill it with balsa?

Hell at least it's on a powerboat and no sailboat thinks this is a good idea.

They'd be better off with a seakeeper, which actually works and doesn't induce drag.

 
Last edited by a moderator:

Starboard!!

Member
328
105
Interesting idea for commercial vessels, but why not just go with the wave-piercing cat concept? Completely impractical for recreational power boats though, because this:

" Dacoma's version is air-filled and computer-controlled, and it swings in a manner tuned to wave action. Known as the Airkeel, it adds about 1.5 meters in draft below the boat, and its lower part is a hollow, oblong compartment filled with air. Its primary target application is for wind farm crew transfer vessels, which need smooth handling for crew comfort. "

 
Last edited by a moderator:

Omer

Anarchist
902
30
What does filling with air means as opposed to an empty chamber. I always thought air occupied any empty space unless filled by any other substance.

As i was reading,  first I thought would this be the opposite of providing righting moment not by weight and gravity but swinging it the other way and use buoyancy? It seems not. 

Mind you, to provide enough righting moment by buoyancy, you would need a huge bulb which would probably do more damage to speed than good.

 

Starboard!!

Member
328
105
Mind you, to provide enough righting moment by buoyancy, you would need a huge bulb which would probably do more damage to speed than good. 
Maybe...  but from a first-principals standpoint, isn't a trimaran using air-filled "bulbs" for stability, rather than the lead filled keels of a monohull? And they are a lot faster.

 

Omer

Anarchist
902
30
Maybe...  but from a first-principals standpoint, isn't a trimaran using air-filled "bulbs" for stability, rather than the lead filled keels of a monohull? And they are a lot faster.
Good point. but you do not stick one of the amas of a trimaran vertically  under the keel  and drag it fully submerged.

 

Airwick

Member
494
233
Victoria, BC
That must use special and hard to obtain 'High Flotation Air' in order to be effective.
I guess if they wanted to maximize boyancy it should be a vacuum in there!

But then it would be looking for an excuse to suck water in and the smallest leak would fill it up completely!

Interesting idea though, I can see a couple potential advantage compared to movable ballast inside the boat for stability control (further from CG, doesn't reduce payload or take up much space inside, maybe easier to retrofit?) but also a lot of downside in terms of maintenance, drag, damage when grounding, increased draft...

 
Top