Steve and Dave Clarks Unidentified Foiling Object

So random question. Of the various UFO's I have seen for sale on SA and other locations, many of them have something along the lines of "used twice, now selling, great condition." Why is it that these boats are only used a couple times then sold? Is it a problem with the boat or people just finding that this type of sailing is too hard or otherwise not for them?
Sellers are rather people who have had changes in their personal live (change of job, a birth....) and have no time to go to sailing. Or also people who have a health problem
But I don't think it's problem with the boat, which is strong, and is an easy sailing dinghy
Mine is 4 years old and is still in great condition
 

martin 'hoff

Super Anarchist
2,309
1,143
Miami
So random question. Of the various UFO's I have seen for sale on SA and other locations, many of them have something along the lines of "used twice, now selling, great condition." Why is it that these boats are only used a couple times then sold? Is it a problem with the boat or people just finding that this type of sailing is too hard or otherwise not for them?
@Gilles29 is right for many/most cases. I've also met folks who had bought the boat on a mistaken understanding – a good female catamaran sailor thought the UFO was close to a Hobie 14, able to easily sail not on foils, beach launched through modest breakers, and then optionally try foiling.

You can sail the UFO with a "flying optional" approach, but beach launch through waves isn't really the strength of any foiler I am aware of. The long foil verticals are just not a match for a beach with breakers.

Kelly Federal and I taught her how to foil it, and she did it well (as a first foiling outing). She also frankly said, this is fun but also not what I had expected. And where she lives, the only practical option is to launch through the breakers.
 

kclo4

New member
6
1
@Gilles29 is right for many/most cases. I've also met folks who had bought the boat on a mistaken understanding – a good female catamaran sailor thought the UFO was close to a Hobie 14, able to easily sail not on foils, beach launched through modest breakers, and then optionally try foiling.

You can sail the UFO with a "flying optional" approach, but beach launch through waves isn't really the strength of any foiler I am aware of. The long foil verticals are just not a match for a beach with breakers.

Kelly Federal and I taught her how to foil it, and she did it well (as a first foiling outing). She also frankly said, this is fun but also not what I had expected. And where she lives, the only practical option is to launch through the breakers.
That is a good point. My main sailing location would be beach launched(and stored) but on the bay side, so not much in the way of breakers. It does stay fairly shallow for a little ways and I would need to keep the main foil full up and the rudder only partial down till I get past the artificial shore erosion barriers, then put everything into place.
My understanding is that this is possible and fairly typical, is that true?
 

martin 'hoff

Super Anarchist
2,309
1,143
Miami
That is a good point. My main sailing location would be beach launched(and stored) but on the bay side, so not much in the way of breakers. It does stay fairly shallow for a little ways and I would need to keep the main foil full up and the rudder only partial down till I get past the artificial shore erosion barriers, then put everything into place.
My understanding is that this is possible and fairly typical, is that true?
Yes, I launch from a protected beach. Needs some technique but entirely doable.

It's extra handy if you have water shoes and can walk it if needed, or get off the boat to turn it or get out of a particular situation.
 

breaqnaway

New member
29
13
Montana
So random question. Of the various UFO's I have seen for sale on SA and other locations, many of them have something along the lines of "used twice, now selling, great condition." Why is it that these boats are only used a couple times then sold? Is it a problem with the boat or people just finding that this type of sailing is too hard or otherwise not for them?
Also curious about this. Looking at Bristol Yacht Clubs Tuesday Foiling Serie (in the Fulcrums backyard...) looks like there are 21 Wingfoilers participating and not a single foiling boat? What gives? Is the cost and "complexity" for dinghy foiling too much vs wingfoiling? Are people foiling for awhile and then going back to their displacement/planing boats?
 

P Flados

Anarchist
747
333
North Carolina
So random question. Of the various UFO's I have seen for sale on SA and other locations, many of them have something along the lines of "used twice, now selling, great condition." Why is it that these boats are only used a couple times then sold? Is it a problem with the boat or people just finding that this type of sailing is too hard or otherwise not for them?

The UFO has some great fun potential, but it has some "issues" that may discourage people.

The "only sailed twice" sounds like a exaggeration, but I can see owners deciding that the UFO was not for them in one season of sailing.

On big item is the learning curve. Foiling the UFO is like learning to ride a bicycle, but an order of magnitude more challenging. As soon as the hulls are out of the water it is easy to "loose the balance" and put a hull in the water. If it is the leeward hull, you have to let out the sail, get back flat and start your run again. This is not painful, but is frustrating. If it is the windward hull, it is much less fun. You will go into the water at a pretty good boat speed. Often you will get your nasal cavities power-washed. If you have done lot of sailing where you primarily used the rudder instead of the mainsheet to deal with wind speed changes, your "bad habits" can make "keeping the balance" a real struggle (I speak from experience).

And then there is the need for getting the foils settings / boat balance just right so that it will take off without having the mainfoil break the surface followed by a high speed nose dive that is in general the least fun way of ending a run in deep water.

Another item that can quickly become a discouragement is the time / effort to transport and rig the boat if you can not leave it with the the mast up and the foils in at your launch location.

You really need a good sailing location that regularly provides good steady foilable wind, has water that is deep enough, is free from bad chop, has reasonable launching provisions, etc. Many buyers probably found that where they though they would sail was not really good enough. This is my worst issue. Every location where I can sail is a PITA in some way or another and all of them are poor with regard to water depth. I have had full speed hard groundings at each location.

I still have my boat but am not sure if I will start trying to sail it again. However, it is definitely not one of those "just sailed a little - in great shape" boats.
 

tdj_sailing

New member
7
2
I suspect DRC meant where on the foil :) When you reviewed the foil after the impact, were there markings showing what part of the foil had made impact? Or other hints – you say the "mount" was bent - is that the metal tang that is integral to the foil horizontal? Are there pics of how it was bent? How did you straighten it?

(Myself, I destroyed a mainfoil after 4+ years of violent groundings against soft sand/grass bottom. Generally speaking, these things can take a beating. But also, my foil looked ok (just scratched) until one day it "cracked" and bent 45 degrees during a foil run. Most likely I broke something inside the foil in a prior run, but wasn't visible externally.)
Hello, I am sorry - I feel quite silly right now for answering with the lake location. I should have thought more about my reply! (I guess its because of people like me that there is a market for t-shirts that say "its in the syllabus"). As DRC said, these foils are strong, and I was actually really suprised the foil even survived given the hard impact it incurred.

Anyways, I checked the main foil and also looked at some old pictures I took last year. So, after the impact with the rock, clearly the front egde was 'chipped' - but on the left side of the foil - see pictures. However, what is interesting, is that my new 'catastrophic' damage (big crack), is on the opposite side, the right side. And the big 'chip' on the left front still looks the same.

And yes, I meant the small aluminum tang that is attached to the foil, and slides into the vertical strut. it was badly bent and twisted after my rock impact last year. I got it back to fit with a combination of 'counter twisting' using two wrenches, and then filing it, to make it a rectangular shape so it would slide into the strut. the end-result was good, it was pretty straight again. My fixed foil worked for a little while, and I had some nice foiling - until yesterday that is.

It sounds like my nose-dive issue would have been the bad foil, so I can go back out with the new foil?

IMG-2269.jpg


IMG-2272.jpg


IMG-2273.jpg


IMG-2274.jpg
 

tdj_sailing

New member
7
2
The UFO has some great fun potential, but it has some "issues" that may discourage people.

The "only sailed twice" sounds like a exaggeration, but I can see owners deciding that the UFO was not for them in one season of sailing.

On big item is the learning curve. Foiling the UFO is like learning to ride a bicycle, but an order of magnitude more challenging. As soon as the hulls are out of the water it is easy to "loose the balance" and put a hull in the water. If it is the leeward hull, you have to let out the sail, get back flat and start your run again. This is not painful, but is frustrating. If it is the windward hull, it is much less fun. You will go into the water at a pretty good boat speed. Often you will get your nasal cavities power-washed. If you have done lot of sailing where you primarily used the rudder instead of the mainsheet to deal with wind speed changes, your "bad habits" can make "keeping the balance" a real struggle (I speak from experience).

And then there is the need for getting the foils settings / boat balance just right so that it will take off without having the mainfoil break the surface followed by a high speed nose dive that is in general the least fun way of ending a run in deep water.

Another item that can quickly become a discouragement is the time / effort to transport and rig the boat if you can not leave it with the the mast up and the foils in at your launch location.

You really need a good sailing location that regularly provides good steady foilable wind, has water that is deep enough, is free from bad chop, has reasonable launching provisions, etc. Many buyers probably found that where they though they would sail was not really good enough. This is my worst issue. Every location where I can sail is a PITA in some way or another and all of them are poor with regard to water depth. I have had full speed hard groundings at each location.

I still have my boat but am not sure if I will start trying to sail it again. However, it is definitely not one of those "just sailed a little - in great shape" boats.
Hi, as a new UFO owner, who incidentally bought from someone who exactly said that, I can relate to this. I'd like to mention that I found the handling of the boat at light wind rather difficult to learn, and not like anything I have experienced on other boats. In particular, the phase of launch/return to shore with only partial rudder is tricky. Tacking is really unique, and I am still learning how to complete the tack swiftly. And finally, being stuck in irons for 15 minutes under strong wind, was another whole experience in itself that puzzled me.

I wish there'd be more 'real world' tutorials and videos, that actually discuss these starter issues unique to UFO. its themundane things such as how to get out of irons, or how to tack. Before buying the UFO I watched the promo-style Youtube videos that showed perfect 'foiliing tacks', which maybe had my expectations wrong - so on my first few times out, when I couldn't even get it to sail straight I certainly had some moments of 'buyers remorse'.

But I love the UFO, I won't give up, and I want to learn and master it. Just like I did with paragliding, maybe 25 years ago.
 

P Flados

Anarchist
747
333
North Carolina
FYI, I remember many occasions early on where I felt like I was "stuck in irons for 15 minutes". At times this was a real issue as tides were pushing me where I really did not want to go.

Later I found an answer that seems to work pretty good.

The thread postings from 9/19/2020 (post-7197718) to 9/23/2020 are a good read for “easier tacking”.

Another good thing to play with for a newbie is what I called "windsurfing a cat" in my 9/21/2019 (post-6730838) and 9/23/2019 (post-6733797) posts. It gives you a different perspective on how you can get the boat moving.
 
Last edited:

tdj_sailing

New member
7
2
FYI, I remember many occasions early on where I felt like I was "stuck in irons for 15 minutes". At times this was a real issue as tides were pushing me where I really did not want to go.

Later I found an answer that seems to work pretty good.

The thread postings from 9/19/2020 (post-7197718) to 9/23/2020 are a good read for “easier tacking”.

Another good thing to play with for a newbie is what I called "windsurfing a cat" in my 9/21/2019 (post-6730838) and 9/23/2019 (post-6733797) posts. It gives you a different perspective on how you can get the boat moving.
Thank you, this was very interesting to read!
 

martin 'hoff

Super Anarchist
2,309
1,143
Miami
I wish there'd be more 'real world' tutorials and videos, that actually discuss these starter issues unique to UFO. its themundane things such as how to get out of irons, or how to tack. Before buying the UFO I watched the promo-style Youtube videos that showed perfect 'foiliing tacks', which maybe had my expectations wrong - so on my first few times out, when I couldn't even get it to sail straight I certainly had some moments of 'buyers remorse'.

But I love the UFO, I won't give up, and I want to learn and master it. Just like I did with paragliding, maybe 25 years ago.
Love the attitude! There's both sets of videos in YT - the glam look-ma-no-hands and the "here's a boring tack" except it's not boring, watch closely and it's showing the subtleties of the technique of... a tack.

All foilers entail a steep learning curve to foil. If you buy a laser or a sunfish, you're initially content with just sailing it. You wouldn't get frustrated that you're not gracefully planing in big waves in-a gusty downwind on your second outing. But on a foiler, that's what you've seen in the cool videos and that's what you want.

Then in reality you have to spend some time learning to rig it, launch it, return (with those painfully long foils), learn to sail it, control it, learn the quirks, then learn to sail it fast. And once you can sail it fast, which would be the start of the big rewards on a regular dinghy, that's the start of the steep learning curve. And the first thing you get is the nasal cleansing :) -- but f it's worth it.
 
Love the attitude! There's both sets of videos in YT - the glam look-ma-no-hands and the "here's a boring tack" except it's not boring, watch closely and it's showing the subtleties of the technique of... a tack.

All foilers entail a steep learning curve to foil. If you buy a laser or a sunfish, you're initially content with just sailing it. You wouldn't get frustrated that you're not gracefully planing in big waves in-a gusty downwind on your second outing. But on a foiler, that's what you've seen in the cool videos and that's what you want.

Then in reality you have to spend some time learning to rig it, launch it, return (with those painfully long foils), learn to sail it, control it, learn the quirks, then learn to sail it fast. And once you can sail it fast, which would be the start of the big rewards on a regular dinghy, that's the start of the steep learning curve. And the first thing you get is the nasal cleansing :) -- but f it's worth it.
My advice, from a UFO nubee…
You’ve bought the equivalent of a Formula 1 Race Car.
No 1. This machine needs to go fast to perform as designed. If there isn’t enough wind to foil, you will probably be disappointed. My low end limit is 10 kts. 15 is better.
No 2. Set up. NantucketGuy has a great setup guide. I printed, laminated and taped it to my sail. Now you have a baseline you can adjust and go back to as you develop a feel for the boat.
No 3. This forum and the unofficial guide. Thousands of hours of other peoples experience will help you from making the mistakes they already made.
No 4. Log every sail. I use an Apple Watch with the Waterspeed App. Real data shows real results.
No 5. Debrief yourself after every sail. What worked, what didn’t. What broke, what can I tweak.
No 6. Results will follow.
We’ve seen the videos of some dude foiling for ever on his first sail of the UFO. Hello, you’re not that dude!
It may take many, many attempts to get there, but don’t give up. You will get there!
 
I wish there'd be more 'real world' tutorials and videos, that actually discuss these starter issues unique to UFO. its themundane things such as how to get out of irons, or how to tack.

There's both sets of videos in YT - the glam look-ma-no-hands and the "here's a boring tack" except it's not boring, watch closely and it's showing the subtleties of the technique of... a tack.
@tdj_sailing , fwiw, I was experiencing many of the same frustrations you’ve described; and one day I mentally threw a switch in my brain to start treating this like an airplane instead of a sailboat. Literally within minutes, I was up and flying in control — all self-taught. So I wince when I hear folks talking about “the learning curve” in the context of the UFO because it depends on which curve you’re operating: on a sailing curve or a flying curve. I think it’s a mistake to think about or treat this like a Laser on steroids. (My mental image is an open-cockpit Stearman biplane.)

When I’m about to put a new foiler on my boat, I not only ask about their sailing background (to understand how much deprogramming I’ll have to do) but also if they have any flying experience. Because if I can start them out by tapping into their flying instincts, THAT learning curve is far steeper and, imo, a better methodology to teaching how to fly this boat.

And, yes, you’re right: there’s a dearth of information on the baby steps for the brand new foiler. Also, when you speak to an experienced foiler, they frequently talk to you as if you’ve already got the basics. Their brain has already shit-canned that crawl-before-walking stuff so it’s difficult for them to relate well with you. That’s why I’ve tried to capture, as best I can, a lot of these learning points here while the experience of learning is still fresh:



Either onboard or offboard video of you flying is very useful if you can get it. And if you have questions that you want to talk through, send me your info via chat and I’m happy to discuss some concepts/techniques that will help you make that jump to foiler. Cheers!
~Kelly
 

ESFoR 2023 Update​

Planning continues for the Early Spring Foiling Rally in Savannah next March. I’m happy to report the following progress:
  • Dave is coming! So, along with unparalleled expertise on the water, you’ll also have access to the guy for any hardware questions. We are planning on having a healthy spares package on hand, but let me know in advance if you have a specific repair or parts issue that you want addressed so we can have the right materials and tools on hand.
  • We are lining up off-water activities not only for inclement weather options, but also to give your travel mates who may have little interest in foiling fun things to do in Savannah while we’re raging around over the water.
  • If your travel companions want to see you foil (or even give it a try themselves), a couple of volunteers here in Savannah have offered up their power boats to use as floating platforms on the river; so in addition to the RHIBs at our disposal, we’ll also have VERY comfortable on-water hang-outs.
Again, if you think you MIGHT come, it really would help me out if you completed this short questionnaire. A more detailed registration will open up later, but some of the info now helps with some planning decisions. Thank you to those who have already completed it. If you’re on the fence about coming or have questions about it before deciding, please reach out to me.

C211C832-30F9-4B9C-AA37-EB3441A40D4C.jpeg
 
Survey question. How much water are your boats normally taking on in an couple to three hour sail?
I’ve noticed when I check after each sail, my boat is taking a healthy 30-45 second wizz.
Is that normal? I have not drilled any new holes in my 2022 boat.
 
Survey question. How much water are your boats normally taking on in an couple to three hour sail?
I’ve noticed when I check after each sail, my boat is taking a healthy 30-45 second wizz.
Is that normal? I have not drilled any new holes in my 2022 boat.
It depends on how many times I’ve submarined that session. If none, then I’ll possibly have nothing dripping out of either drain hole. In Bristol with heavy conditions and several submarine events, I had about 20 solid secs of drainage to get rid of.
 
It depends on how many times I’ve submarined that session. If none, then I’ll possibly have nothing dripping out of either drain hole. In Bristol with heavy conditions and several submarine events, I had about 20 solid secs of drainage to get rid of.
I just ripped around today with 3 knockdowns, 2 full submarines that I drove out of and no turtles. Very little drainage. It must have something to do with capsizing. Thanks KF!
Finally got my GoPro to record the whole thing! Critique, I wasn’t foiling as much as I thought I was. 13+ kt wind but out of the wrong direction coupled with a strong tide meant I had to constantly sail upwind stay in my area code. I’m finding the pointing characteristics of the UFO quite poor. I’m dreading foiling downwind, simply because it’s too much work to get back upwind. Any advice?
 
I just ripped around today with 3 knockdowns, 2 full submarines that I drove out of and no turtles. Very little drainage. It must have something to do with capsizing. Thanks KF!
Finally got my GoPro to record the whole thing! Critique, I wasn’t foiling as much as I thought I was. 13+ kt wind but out of the wrong direction coupled with a strong tide meant I had to constantly sail upwind stay in my area code. I’m finding the pointing characteristics of the UFO quite poor. I’m dreading foiling downwind, simply because it’s too much work to get back upwind. Any advice?
You should be dreading going downwind because it’s unstable and crash-prone, not because going upwind is hard.

If I can get up on foils, I will out-VMG any displacement dinghy upwind. I actually will be heading 3-5 degrees below them, but with a healthy heel to windward, I will be tracking 5+ degrees higher and at twice the speed. I will lose ground initially when I bear away to get up on foils, and I need enough real estate to capitalize on the foiling gains before tacking and starting over again.

If I don’t have enough room to use the foils to make upwind distance and am therefore confined to beat upwind in displacement mode, I’ve found that I can track just as well as a Sunfish but a tad slower. (And I don’t dare pinch too high.) Weight is as far forward as I dare without submarining, and inboard/outboard as necessary to keep the boat flat. Maybe this technique helps you.

The next two UFO 101 videos I’m working on pertain to these topics. Your questions are motivation for me to keep pressing forward with those.

Can’t wait to see some of your video!
 

JC843

New member
Wanted to repost- my lightly used, factory refurbished ufo is still for sale in Charleston, SC. Also- just to chime in on the above questions as to why people sell a lightly used boat: in my case the answer is simply due to the fact that my specific location is just not a feasible place to launch or retrieve the boat from. I have been very happy with the boat, and wish I could have used it more, but since I don’t- it is for sale.
 

martin 'hoff

Super Anarchist
2,309
1,143
Miami
I just ripped around today with 3 knockdowns, 2 full submarines that I drove out of and no turtles. Very little drainage. It must have something to do with capsizing. Thanks KF!
Finally got my GoPro to record the whole thing! Critique, I wasn’t foiling as much as I thought I was. 13+ kt wind but out of the wrong direction coupled with a strong tide meant I had to constantly sail upwind stay in my area code. I’m finding the pointing characteristics of the UFO quite poor. I’m dreading foiling downwind, simply because it’s too much work to get back upwind. Any advice?
What Kelly said. Once you're good dw and uw, both are super fast fun. Dw has much better VMG so you sail upwind for longer but it's not a drag...
 


Latest posts





Top