Supreme Court will overturn Roe v Wade

Grrr...

▰▰▰▰▰▰▰▰▰▰ 100%
10,657
2,945
Detroit
And the "its only up to the woman crowd" seem to have a lot of opinions here.  Any of you parents? If the mom had decided at say 25 weeks to go and abort your kid, you are going to sit here and say that you have (had) no right to say anything or do anything about that? Is that your position.

And please don't reply with insults, you just look even dumber.
You realize that you are very quickly proving that your claims about supporting abortion are  transparently false as you present all sorts of evidence and ideas supporting its ban, right? 

And yes.  We are parents.  And my wife is a nurse.  And religious.  And she still thinks it is absolute INSANITY for you to try to impose your moral views on her body. 

 
Last edited by a moderator:

d'ranger

Super Anarchist
30,249
5,226
You obviously didn't do any real examination into your false assessment...  The link provided show that the vast majority of Europe has very similar laws that the majority of Americans agree with (about 70% regardless of political affiliation) within the first trimester. Beyond that it breaks down to needs of the patient (mother).  

 BBC News - Europe's abortion rule
And exactly how does that differ from what I wrote? Try again.  Ectopic pregnancy? Rape? I could go on but in my part of the world a woman gets no say and the best to hope for is nothing after 6 weeks. Doesn't realize she is pregnant? Tough shit. Of course the push is to get the law passed to outlaw abortions. Period. Full stop. No exceptions.  Unless the life of the mother is threatened? Okay and who gets to decide that? Texas has already pushed to make abortion a crime and anyone can turn them in and get a reward.

yee haw.

 

Monkey

Super Anarchist
11,381
3,054
Nope. Though about 98.7% of all abortions happen in the first 20 weeks, so that would cover most non-medically necessitated abortions it's not enough. You need to be able to terminate a pregnancy at any point the life of the mother would be endangered by continuing it.

The current status - which severely limits 3rd trimester options and limits some 2nd tri options - is workable, although not ideal. 3rd trimester abortions, despite all the wild hype by the lying pro-lifers, are so rare as to be basically a statistical anomaly.

The theory that someone could terminate a 38 week fetus is ridiculous - no one does that. Pretty much all tests and exams that show a non-viable pregnancy are done well before then. But that does not mean we have a right to tell women not to, though there will not be able to find a doctor at that point to do the procedure so the point is moot - any OB/Gyn would just induce delivery.

Most abortions - about 90% - happen in the first trimester.

ACOG - pretty much the authority on women's health:

https://www.acog.org/clinical/clinical-guidance/practice-bulletin/articles/2013/06/second-trimester-abortion

https://www.bmj.com/company/newsroom/nine-out-of-10-abortions-done-before-12-weeks-in-many-high-income-countries/

A different view on the data:

https://www.motherjones.com/kevin-drum/2019/04/raw-data-abortions-by-week-of-pregnancy/

I completely agree. I’ll actually vote left in the midterms with the hope that this finally gets properly put into law. 
 

It’s not a big sacrifice, the GOP has so utterly gone off the rails, normal conservatives like me have completely abandoned them. 

 

Not My Real Name

Not Actually Me
43,216
2,946
Abortion in France is legal on demand during the first 14 weeks of pregnancy ...  ... Abortion in Germany is legal during the first trimester of pregnancy, with exceptions later in pregnancy for physical or mental health reasons  ...    ...
Yeah but those are both VERY LIBERAL COUNTRIES... goddam heathen commies!

- DSK
France has had a VERY strong Catholic population, and that has held a lot of sway in keeping abortion rights somewhat checked. Though the trend is reversing.

Ah, the memories of arguing about abortion with my very Catholic, very French French teacher in 10th grade.

 

Not My Real Name

Not Actually Me
43,216
2,946
I completely agree. I’ll actually vote left in the midterms with the hope that this finally gets properly put into law. 
 

It’s not a big sacrifice, the GOP has so utterly gone off the rails, normal conservatives like me have completely abandoned them. 
Good to here.

And here I thought I was one of the only people you ever put on Ignore.

 

Raz'r

Super Anarchist
64,069
6,423
De Nile
I completely agree. I’ll actually vote left in the midterms with the hope that this finally gets properly put into law. 
 

It’s not a big sacrifice, the GOP has so utterly gone off the rails, normal conservatives like me have completely abandoned them. 
Welcome to the party, I jumped ship in 2004...

 

Monkey

Super Anarchist
11,381
3,054
Good to here.

And here I thought I was one of the only people you ever put on Ignore.
I’ve never put you on ignore. We’ve fought a bunch, but I respect dissenting opinions. It helps me learn different views. As far I as I know, AJ and Randumb are the only two folks from PA I’ve ever ignored, and that’s just because they act like trolls. I’ll completely admit I call you out when I think you argue like a hypocrite, but respect when it comes back at me. Conversations are just a little heated on PA. 

 

Monkey

Super Anarchist
11,381
3,054
Welcome to the party, I jumped ship in 2004...
I’m definitely not “in the party”. There’s plenty of stupid in that party as well. I’m currently just siding with the lesser of two evils. 

 

Raz'r

Super Anarchist
64,069
6,423
De Nile
It's Virginia.  Going to answer his question/hypothetical now?
I don't live in Virginia.

As far as it goes though, my spouse, or baby partner as the case may be, would have 100% say in whatever medical procedures she undergoes.

Seems like if something at 27 week was really an issue (although virginia says it's 25, whatever) then you could address it with state legislators in Virginia.

 

Marty Gingras

Mid-range Anarchist
I don't live in Virginia.

As far as it goes though, my spouse, or baby partner as the case may be, would have 100% say in whatever medical procedures she undergoes.

Seems like if something at 27 week was really an issue (although virginia says it's 25, whatever) then you could address it with state legislators in Virginia.
Thanks.  I suspect [email protected] understands a bit better now where you are coming from.  It's his turn to enable likewise w/regard to the three key questions/clarifications we've sought from him.

 
Last edited by a moderator:

Steam Flyer

Sophisticated Yet Humble
48,358
11,903
Eastern NC
It’s not a big sacrifice, the GOP has so utterly gone off the rails, normal conservatives like me have completely abandoned them. 
Welcome to the party, I jumped ship in 2004...
My father, who described himself as a "hereditary Republican," disliked Dick Cheney before he was Vice President and could not stomach the GOP endorsing torture. Somewhere in that same 2003~2005 time frame, he told me that he would never vote for another Republican as long as he lived. I thought that was overly harsh.

I’m definitely not “in the party”. There’s plenty of stupid in that party as well. I’m currently just siding with the lesser of two evils. 
Unfortunately, that is often the way of it. I have never been a fan of partisan politics, nor loyal to a party. I've always voted either for the best candidate or against the worst candidate. Lately all the Republicans I see running are either hateful pinheads, or playing the part. I remember when a higher percentage of Democrats than Republicans were segregationists, and I fully expect to see this flop again.

- DSK

 
2,512
379
USA
I would do anything humanly possible, within the bounds of the law, to stop my children's mother from harming my children, and that includes the time before they were born. 

I don't have an opinion on the jail time question because as I've stated that while I do support the rights of the unborn once the fetus is viable outside of the woman's body, I do not support the draconian and extreme anti-abortion measures being enacted by Republican controlled states across the country.

 


Latest posts





Top