The absolute JOKE that is American Health Care

mathystuff

Super Anarchist
1,253
886
because the insurance company doesn't pay list, either. I spent 4 days in Stanford Hospital system, couple years back. Bill was north of $100k. Insurance paid about $13k
Instant financial ruin for what 1/3? 1/2? the people. Awesome system. Would have cost you 40€ here.
 

F_L

Anarchist
846
164
Canyon Lake, TX
Hospitals do not collect ‘charges’. Typical collections are 40-50% of billed $, unless it’s a case involving an attorney or auto insurance.

Hospital finances are very convoluted.
I know insurance companies negotiate prices with medical providers. I'm not sure how realistic are the "retail prices" I was quoted. If we had run Mrs F_L's bill thru insurance would it have been about the same?
My doctor said when he gets close to retirement he will probably go the boutique route. He owns a decent sized clinic. Rent it out to a couple of others doctors, maintain an office there. He said if he quits taking insurance he will only see patients a couple of days per week.
 

Bristol-Cruiser

Super Anarchist
5,158
1,690
Great Lakes
But you have provided those measures, only stated your opinion. If the quality and availability of healthcare was so good the outcomes like LE and child mortality would be more in keeping with the usual suspects - Western Europe, Canada, Japan, Oz, et al and they certainly are not.

Have a look at the CIA Facebook, it is quite good. It identifies the realties of North Korea, Russia, Sweden and the US by providing comparative data. I can only picture some guy picking up women in a bar and talking about working for the CIA, when all he does is data collection and presentation in a cubical in the basement.
Did I miss V3's reply to this post?
 

130lights

Super Anarchist
1,388
953
Lake Michigan
I know insurance companies negotiate prices with medical providers. I'm not sure how realistic are the "retail prices" I was quoted. If we had run Mrs F_L's bill thru insurance would it have been about the same?
My doctor said when he gets close to retirement he will probably go the boutique route. He owns a decent sized clinic. Rent it out to a couple of others doctors, maintain an office there. He said if he quits taking insurance he will only see patients a couple of days per week.
I’m thinking about the same. I worked in hospital finance (not the billing area)for about 30 years, all at large non-profit facilities. The for profits operate very differently.

The boutique practices would be interesting, but I’m not sure how successful they would be in Michigan…maybe in a few of the areas.
 

Grrr...

▰▰▰▰▰▰▰▰▰▰ 100%
10,633
2,920
Detroit
because the insurance company doesn't pay list, either. I spent 4 days in Stanford Hospital system, couple years back. Bill was north of $100k. Insurance paid about $13k
Either price would cause 1/4 of the people in this country to go bankrupt.
 

Happy

Super Anarchist
3,128
1,801
Tropical Oz
American health care story:

When Top Gear were filming in the US, they employed a guy to wash the cars. Full-time job, cleaning between shots etc.

He had to be paid in cash off the books.
He was driving home after work in LA, sitting at a red light, when he was rear-ended hard by a drunk off-duty LA cop. Fuel tank went up, he was knocked out and belted in, major burns. No health cover.

He spent a long time in hospital, they fucked up the repairs, and left him with a bill for over $600K.

So for the rest of his life, he has to work off the books or get a ton of legal shit for money he doesn't have.

And the off-duty drunk cop who hit him? No prosecution, no consequences.
 

BeSafe

Super Anarchist
8,277
1,526
One thing that has happened that I didn't realize is how many people are now using public funded options. Its moved faster than I thought it had.

Medicaid - the state level / federal paid system including CHIPS has ~ 90 million people.
Medicare - the direct federal program - has about 65 million.

Total ~ 155 million people.
Total US population ~ 332 million people.

So roughly 50% of the population is already on a government option directly.

Of the remaining 50%, approximately 57% of them are on the government-framed high-deductable plan. So that's private health care but the boundary conditions are set by the government.

If 8 people get together for a dinner party, only two of them have something approximating a 'free market health care plan.' The other 6 are already in the government system. We're much closer to single payer than I thought we'd be by this point. My bet is with natural demographics, we're up over 90% by the end of Biden II.
 

Bristol-Cruiser

Super Anarchist
5,158
1,690
Great Lakes
Years ago NPR had a wonderful documentary about healthcare in the US. The conclusion was that the US had an inefficient amalgam of what is found in Canada (Medicare), UK (veterans' care), Germany (private plans), and the third world. It hasn't gotten less fragmented now. I don't see a way out of the mess - too many entities have too much to lose.
 

billy backstay

Backstay, never bought a suit, never went to Vegas
Years ago NPR had a wonderful documentary about healthcare in the US. The conclusion was that the US had an inefficient amalgam of what is found in Canada (Medicare), UK (veterans' care), Germany (private plans), and the third world. It hasn't gotten less fragmented now. I don't see a way out of the mess - too many entities have too much to lose.

This is fairly recent, so probably not what you are referring to??

FRONTLINE & NPR Investigate "The Healthcare Divide" in America​


 

veni vidi vici

Omne quod audimus est opinio, non res. Omnia videm
8,959
2,120
Years ago NPR had a wonderful documentary about healthcare in the US. The conclusion was that the US had an inefficient amalgam of what is found in Canada (Medicare), UK (veterans' care), Germany (private plans), and the third world. It hasn't gotten less fragmented now. I don't see a way out of the mess - too many entities have too much to lose.
Commie
National Panhandler Radio
 

Steam Flyer

Sophisticated Yet Humble
48,158
11,778
Eastern NC

Ah, good- an actual news source instead of RWNJ spew.

(from the above link)- "Based on a report in Tuesday’s edition of Spain’s El Pais newspaper, the doctors -- who have no first-hand knowledge of Castro’s condition -- said Castro had received questionable or even botched care at the hands of health experts on his communist-ruled island."

So- this particular health care did not take place in Spain
2- the doctors being quoted had NO actual knowledge of Castro's condition before or after
3- outside the scope of this particular news story, but relevant: Castro lived a hell of a lot longer than you are likely to

The good news, this little article supports the RWNJ spew which always asserts the mainstream media is not reliable. OTOH unlike RWNJ spew, -this- article gave the relevants facts to judge it appropriately.
 
Top