jackolantern
Super Anarchist
- 1,576
- 444
Is this the J/88 Mould?
I thought it would have been but it’s narrower on the spec sheet so could be a bespoke mouldIs this the J/88 Mould?
Thanks, I hadn’t seen them earlier in the drop down menu...
Also a foot shorterI thought it would have been but it’s narrower on the spec sheet so could be a bespoke mould
108 is a gift from the gods..............Depends on the area, rating and course. In PHRF NE Melges 24's rate 108.
In W/L racing in breeze and waves they don't do that well. The larger boats that rate the same or close can punch through the chop better. They get hammed to the first mark and can't recover downwind.
In point to point racing with the kite up in breeze they're virtually untouchable.
The 121 has been out a few years. Personally I wouldn’t be surprised to see something in the 43-45’ range. This is the first time since the 44 was introduced in 1989 that they haven’t offered a single boat over 40’.
A couple of years ago at the Annapolis boat show the J people were hinting at coming out with a mid 40 foot cruising boat.Looks like I nailed this one
I'm not sure if J will start to follow the scow designs, but that would be one option that would really show a performance improvement (in certain conditions of course).So I have been scheming and dreaming about my next boat which would naturally be a J/99 or more likely a J/111. Being used to product cycles today, I am seemingly reluctant to buy a decade old product probably because of the risk that a zoomier new design will come along that will diminish the value of the J/111.
Is it the case that there is little they can do to better a design like this so it won't likely be replaced by a similar but better product even if it is a decade old?
Dan
Have sailed one, albeit one with a wheel instead of tiller, and it hasn't blown me away, but they seem to make a good compromise between racer and cruiser, and very easy to handle...So I have been scheming and dreaming about my next boat which would naturally be a J/99
Its pretty much all about timing, how long do you want to wait, and how much you want to spend. With the full disclosure that I own a J/111, I want you to be aware of my bias:So I have been scheming and dreaming about my next boat which would naturally be a J/99 or more likely a J/111. Being used to product cycles today, I am seemingly reluctant to buy a decade old product probably because of the risk that a zoomier new design will come along that will diminish the value of the J/111.
Is it the case that there is little they can do to better a design like this so it won't likely be replaced by a similar but better product even if it is a decade old?
Dan
Fantastic response with lots of very valid points so thanks for taking the time to write it out. I do understand the bias and congratulate you on owning a boat you feel that way about.Its pretty much all about timing, how long do you want to wait, and how much you want to spend. With the full disclosure that I own a J/111, I want you to be aware of my bias:
Not buying a J/111 today:
1. New design comes out and its epic. Cost of buying the new boat will be $500 - $750k for a 40+ boat? Look at the pricing of the J121 when it first came out. But if you can handle the prices on new toys vs old toys, why buy used?
2. Usually J-boat comes out with a new design when the used boat market = 50% of a new one, and we are there. If a new design comes out that rocks, the J/111 will be worth less money and you are throwing money away
3. Old boats
4. Waterline is amazing going upwind in a blow; 36.5 feet isnt a lot of waterline vs the rating
Reason to buy a J/111 today:
1. Once the new design comes out, it will take some time to see if its a good / race winning boat the race to her rating
2. Cost vs a new boat; no comparison. Used boats are great values, assuming you get a good one
3. They are fast boats than can win in a variety of conditions
4. They plane downwind in 17+ knots
5. Strong race record in multiple countries
6. A few weeks ago, before we got the spin up, we were doing 15.6 knots with just the jib up. Fun factor is huge
7. Look at the J-105, J-109 races .... still a boats racing shows that the classes have long legs.
With the caveat I have nothing to do with the marine industry, i have noticed that J-boats puts out a new model when the price of the used boats = 50% of the price when it was new. It could help them on the timing of when they can get the biggest bang out of a new model ... but its an observation and thats it.Fantastic response with lots of very valid points so thanks for taking the time to write it out. I do understand the bias and congratulate you on owning a boat you feel that way about.
I don't understand point 2 above referring to the used market = 50% of new. Is that the price in the used market?
Thanks again, Dan